(Jan. 05, 2021 4:12 AM)Admiral W Wrote: [ -> ]Something that frustrates me about Sparking and by extension a good deal of the seasons is why simple details from the manga aren't included. Things that it would be easy to introduce and would really only require a tweak here or there to the script. Then there's huge swaths of story that are superior to what we got in anime. Hikaru's retirement from blading in the manga is an excellent peice of character work excluded from the anime. So much wasted potential.
It’s quite simple, the anime is meant for promoting the beys whereas the manga is meant to be a story.
(Jan. 05, 2021 4:15 AM)6Jupiter5 Wrote: [ -> ] (Jan. 05, 2021 4:12 AM)Admiral W Wrote: [ -> ]Something that frustrates me about Sparking and by extension a good deal of the seasons is why simple details from the manga aren't included. Things that it would be easy to introduce and would really only require a tweak here or there to the script. Then there's huge swaths of story that are superior to what we got in anime. Hikaru's retirement from blading in the manga is an excellent peice of character work excluded from the anime. So much wasted potential.
It’s quite simple, the anime is meant for promoting the beys whereas the manga is meant to be a story.
A good story can still be told while promoting the beys. Season 1 & 2 are an excellent example of that. In addition adapting the manga more closely wouldn't interfere with that.
(Jan. 05, 2021 4:18 AM)Admiral W Wrote: [ -> ] (Jan. 05, 2021 4:15 AM)6Jupiter5 Wrote: [ -> ]It’s quite simple, the anime is meant for promoting the beys whereas the manga is meant to be a story.
A good story can still be told while promoting the beys. Season 1 & 2 are an excellent example of that. In addition adapting the manga more closely wouldn't interfere with that.
Manga is much more concise and simple so it kind of would interfere with it. The thing is, it works for manga since it’s not
animation but it doesn’t quite work like that for anime. I do think that the structure and story arcs of the manga should be used though.
(Jan. 05, 2021 4:20 AM)Zeutron Wrote: [ -> ] (Jan. 05, 2021 4:18 AM)Admiral W Wrote: [ -> ]A good story can still be told while promoting the beys. Season 1 & 2 are an excellent example of that. In addition adapting the manga more closely wouldn't interfere with that.
Manga is much more concise and simple so it kind of would interfere with it. The thing is, it works for manga since it’s not
animation but it doesn’t quite work like that for anime.
I'd disagree with that. Season 1 & 2 were very close to the manga and as a result are the most beloved of the seasons and at the same time promoted the beys.
(Jan. 05, 2021 4:22 AM)Admiral W Wrote: [ -> ] (Jan. 05, 2021 4:20 AM)Zeutron Wrote: [ -> ]Manga is much more concise and simple so it kind of would interfere with it. The thing is, it works for manga since it’s not
animation but it doesn’t quite work like that for anime.
I'd disagree with that. Season 1 & 2 were very close to the manga and as a result are the most beloved of the seasons and at the same time promoted the beys.
I haven’t really read the s1 manga so I can’t speak for it but the s2 manga seemed very concise to me. I guess we all have our own standards of what we feel is concise.
Yeah Imma be off topic only for saying this:
Season 1 & 2 are basically like G-Revolution and Metal Masters cause these seasons are good.
Season 3 was basically V-Force and Shogun Steel all over the place.
Season 4 and Season 5 is 2000 and Metal Fusion combined.
(Jan. 05, 2021 4:24 AM)Zeutron Wrote: [ -> ] (Jan. 05, 2021 4:22 AM)Admiral W Wrote: [ -> ]I'd disagree with that. Season 1 & 2 were very close to the manga and as a result are the most beloved of the seasons and at the same time promoted the beys.
I haven’t really read the s1 manga so I can’t speak for it but the s2 manga seemed very concise to me. I guess we all have our own standards of what we feel is concise.
Perhaps we differ on our view of concision. They explored things very well in the manga and a good deal of it translated to the screen. In all adaptions you can't include everything, but when the main breadth of the story is translated from page to the screen is when Burst succeeds the most. The anime suffers when it strays far from the source material.
(Jan. 05, 2021 4:24 AM)Zeutron Wrote: [ -> ] (Jan. 05, 2021 4:22 AM)Admiral W Wrote: [ -> ]I'd disagree with that. Season 1 & 2 were very close to the manga and as a result are the most beloved of the seasons and at the same time promoted the beys.
I haven’t really read the s1 manga so I can’t speak for it but the s2 manga seemed very concise to me. I guess we all have our own standards of what we feel is concise.
Well imo I think Season 1 and god anime is superior to the manga, lui late introduction in the manga is just not it for me personally (burst S1 ep38-39 is a better introduction) and valt not having ptsd about lui in the manga for me just makes the battle a little bit weak imo
As for god the manga finale was sorter which is why i like the anime better but it did close the astem mask thinggy
(Jan. 05, 2021 4:28 AM)Admiral W Wrote: [ -> ] (Jan. 05, 2021 4:24 AM)Zeutron Wrote: [ -> ]I haven’t really read the s1 manga so I can’t speak for it but the s2 manga seemed very concise to me. I guess we all have our own standards of what we feel is concise.
Perhaps we differ on our view of concision. They explored things very well in the manga and a good deal of it translated to the screen. In all adaptions you can't include everything, but when the main breadth of the story is translated from page to the screen is when Burst succeeds the most. The anime suffers when it strays far from the source material.
It’s definitely not completely accurate but I wouldn’t say it strays far from source material uk? It’s basically the anime as if different events occurred in a more coordinated manner. I think Hiro Morita would be a great addition to the writers of the anime but they’d never be able to pay him enough. He’s probably more passionate about manga anyways.
So what your all saying is the manga is better than anime right?
(Jan. 05, 2021 4:32 AM)EarthHelios Wrote: [ -> ]So what your all saying is the manga is better than anime right?
Sometimes it is. Generally speaking I would say that beyblade manga usually is better. The writers of the manga are the creators of the characters after all.
I don't honestly think there will be any more beys breaking. I mean there is no point for that to happen anymore.
(Jan. 05, 2021 4:31 AM)Zeutron Wrote: [ -> ] (Jan. 05, 2021 4:28 AM)Admiral W Wrote: [ -> ]Perhaps we differ on our view of concision. They explored things very well in the manga and a good deal of it translated to the screen. In all adaptions you can't include everything, but when the main breadth of the story is translated from page to the screen is when Burst succeeds the most. The anime suffers when it strays far from the source material.
It’s definitely not completely accurate but I wouldn’t say it strays far from source material uk? It’s basically the anime as if different events occurred in a more coordinated manner. I think Hiro Morita would be a great addition to the writers of the anime but they’d never be able to pay him enough. He’s probably more passionate about manga anyways.
Certain beats are included but in many respects the story of the anime diverges significantly from the manga. Lots of crucial story points get completely left out. The My Hero Academia series is an excellent example of a superb manga to anime adaptation.
(Jan. 05, 2021 4:32 AM)EarthHelios Wrote: [ -> ]So what your all saying is the manga is better than anime right?
I would say the manga is better cho-z onwards
How would you say they handle the main characters in anime and manga
(Jan. 05, 2021 4:35 AM)Needforspeed Wrote: [ -> ] (Jan. 05, 2021 4:32 AM)EarthHelios Wrote: [ -> ]So what your all saying is the manga is better than anime right?
I would say the manga is better cho-z onwards
I agree wholeheartedly. Season 1 & 2 are pretty close to the manga already so there about on par for me.
(Jan. 05, 2021 4:37 AM)EarthHelios Wrote: [ -> ]How would you say they handle the main characters in anime and manga
For valt it's on par
For aiga anime handles it a little bit better
For drum definitely manga
For Hyuga and hikaru as for right now probably manga
(Jan. 05, 2021 4:34 AM)EarthHelios Wrote: [ -> ]I don't honestly think there will be any more beys breaking. I mean there is no point for that to happen anymore.
Beys breaking would be pretty cool. Honestly, Lane's motivationation should be to destroy all beys instead of beating the Legends.
(Jan. 05, 2021 4:48 AM)rainy days Wrote: [ -> ] (Jan. 05, 2021 4:34 AM)EarthHelios Wrote: [ -> ]I don't honestly think there will be any more beys breaking. I mean there is no point for that to happen anymore.
Beys breaking would be pretty cool. Honestly, Lane's motivationation should be to destroy all beys instead of beating the Legends.
even if he destroyed the legends beys it would be pointless. as the can just repaired it theirs no impact on destroying them at all . look at ranjiro his bey got broken and boom got repaired. bey breaking lost it's meaning after cho z introduced they can repaired them the next day and besides the matches are by pairs ane won't be able to break without interference even he wanted either way.
Infinite Achilles, Rantaro's Glide Ragnaruk, Curse Satan, and possibly Tempest Dragon would get destroyed lol
(Jan. 05, 2021 5:08 AM)EarthHelios Wrote: [ -> ]Infinite Achilles, Rantaro's Glide Ragnaruk, Curse Satan, and possibly Tempest Dragon would get destroyed lol
The only one who destroy a bey would be Lane, he already battled Aiger so he wouldn't get a chance to break Achilles or Ranjiro's Roktavor. Not much point to any beys breaking since it most cases it's done so new beys can replace them.
I kind of like it that Lane doesn’t overly enjoy breaking beys like other beys we get.
Either Im stupid or something but I feel like Lane will lose 4 times overall in Sparking
(Jan. 05, 2021 5:26 AM)EarthHelios Wrote: [ -> ]Either Im stupid or something but I feel like Lane will lose 4 times overall in Sparking
That's so random lol.
(Jan. 05, 2021 4:22 AM)Admiral W Wrote: [ -> ] (Jan. 05, 2021 4:20 AM)Zeutron Wrote: [ -> ]Manga is much more concise and simple so it kind of would interfere with it. The thing is, it works for manga since it’s not
animation but it doesn’t quite work like that for anime.
I'd disagree with that. Season 1 & 2 were very close to the manga and as a result are the most beloved of the seasons and at the same time promoted the beys.
Yeah
(Jan. 05, 2021 4:48 AM)rainy days Wrote: [ -> ] (Jan. 05, 2021 4:34 AM)EarthHelios Wrote: [ -> ]I don't honestly think there will be any more beys breaking. I mean there is no point for that to happen anymore.
Beys breaking would be pretty cool. Honestly, Lane's motivationation should be to destroy all beys instead of beating the Legends.
He would be pulling a phi lol