(Mar. 23, 2022 7:10 PM)DeceasedCrab Wrote: You don't call someone else's decisions, that they have already explained, for an unranked testing tournament, inferior, or skewed. That's the rudest, and he did both across 2 posts. At that point, no future positive communication is even possible, and should be discouraged or prevented.
I'm literally convinced that is someone's alt troll account. I would like that investigated by staff, honestly, because out of 3 total posts 2 are in this thread. If it's not, then I would still discourage them from what they did.
At this point I question whether or not the tournament should be held at all. Very few people put in the actual meaningful work of running unranked tournaments to test new formats or beystadiums. Everyone and everyone is willing to voice loud opinions about it, but not do anything that actually leads towards usable data for staff to consider. Is it even worth it?
The pocket wall bounce rule is an artifact of the MFB era dragged into Burst for the sake of consistency, since gaps were replaced with pockets with open floors. The Haspro beystadium, like many Hasbro ones, has no intention for out of stadium KOs to be an option, unlike B-09, so the pocket wall bounce rule doesn't make sense for it.
Given that there are now 4 Pockets on Haspro, of a potentially shallow depth, having to continuously check for possible pocket wall bounces on video for an entire unranked tournament where they seem potentially more likely for a KO situation that literally cannot happen by design is overkill. We're not implementing the pocket wall bounce KO rule for this tournament.
Well, it's generally accepted consensus that having the wall bounce rule is better for gameplay balance, so I don't know why you're this miffed about it and consider it a rulebreak, it clearly isn't. I'm sorry if you think it was an attack on you and your event specifically - it's just that I don't want to see the pro series stadium discarded because of poor conditions, a la blue clay in tennis, as would happen if you didn't use fair rules.
Regarding the pocket wall bounce rule: so you want to play the stadium as close to intended as possible? Shouldn't the goal be to try to make the stadium as balanced as possible? If you don't want to put in the work to check for kos to happen as they should, then maybe leave the testing to someone else here? I mean, in ranked tournaments, it would unheard of for an organizer to decide not to check footage for a supposed back-wall bounce KO.
Again, I don't mean anything hurtful by this, I'm sorry if that's what you got out of it. I'm just trying to make sure that the testing is as fair and as applicable to how the stadium would be in real tournament use as possible, and if you disagree, you could do so more nicely than to ruleshark and say "Ideally this is the last thing I read from you ever again" after a single post that doesn't even break a rule, or than calling someone a troll for trying to be amicable about tournament ruling.
Actually, while I'm at it - I'd like to deconstruct this.
(Mar. 23, 2022 7:10 PM)DeceasedCrab Wrote: You don't call someone else's decisions, that they have already explained
You haven't explained anything. Others on the topic have mentioned that the stadium's tornado ridge is taller, beys stay in there more than they would in the b09, and that KOs are slightly less common. In fact, to quote friedpasta: "The Pro Series stadium already has a myriad of ways to make KOs harder than the currently legal stadiums. Firstly, the tornado ridge is significantly taller, causing certain drivers to catch the ridge better and thus many drivers that are very punishable with attack will already become harder to KO. There’s also a higher ratio of wall to actual pocket in this stadium. Furthermore, the pockets are pretty small, so beys are gonna be even more prone to bouncing back than in the B-09, especially the pocket with the peg-leg thingy."
However, rather than actually addressing any of these with true justifications, or testing proving that the gaps caused by those factors between the pro series stadium and the TT standard are minimal, all you have said is that you don't think the same way and provided the bare minimum of what can be considered anecdote.
Also, not a he.
- Abellia