(Sep. 12, 2014 3:22 AM)Wombat Wrote: I'm okay with removing Pisces from Omega, but I've never tried it. Will Lacerta work? It's roughly the same shape as Horuseus.
I tested literally every CW I ownded with Omega, and none worked nearly as well as Horuseus or Pegasis III (except, surprisingly, for Unicorno, but it wasn't quite on level with Pegasis II and Horuseus was far better).
Quote:I'm still iffy about Beat, but if it goes up GB145 should be added. I was doing some Vulcan tests before I broke my wrist and it was holding pretty even with Lightning and Screw. Once I get my cast off I'll finish and post them. I remember th!nk saying Cosmic worked best as a Force Smasher and that's why he had it on TH170/SR200.
I thought I put GB145 on there. Hmmm, guess I didn't. I'll add it. Thanks for pointing that out.
Quote:Also, no Samurai on Wyvang? I'm not a huge fan of Wyvang but isn't that the usual Right Spin setup? And doesn't work as well on 145 height as it does on a shorter Track.
th!nk did testing with Wyvang Attack combinations, and both he and I found that Gladiator and Shinobi are pretty much flat-out superior to Samurai for right-spin Attack. Samurai is like the smoothest Crystal Wheel in the game, so using it for Attack doesn't make much sense, haha.
Quote:Seriously though what is your beef with CS? It's a great Defensive part; it's just that its problem in Standard is that it can't keep up with the heavier metagame. It works perfectly fine in Limited.
I don't have a "beef" with CS - it just isn't as solid as other Defensive Bottoms (and actually, I'd say it's even worse comparatively in Limited than it is in Standard - th!nk did plenty of testing with it, and he was strongly in favor of its total removal).
Quote:I'm pretty sure that the community agreed recently that Cancer and Cygnus are for all purposes better than Aquario, not quite sure why you put it up there.
It's still listed for Defense on the STD tier list. I could see it being removed at some point, but that's why I put it up there.
Quote:WD and EWD > D and SD on 85, so I consolidated the two. Maybe 90 should be added because sometimes 85 scrapes. Also you seem to have forgotten SR200TB was a thing. I remember you explicitly saying that TB was your favorite Tall Track Stamina Tip.
Are you sure about that? I've done testing with Earth 85 and SD out-spins WD relatively reliably for me. Also, IIRC the testing that established SD as a competitive Stamina part was done at least partially with early low-Track Stamina customs. Could be wrong, but that's the impression I was under. I see no reason not to list them TBH.
TB was tested (by yours truly and multiple others) and proved ineffective with lightweight Limited Format Stamina setups. It stinks, but it really doesn't work.
It's my favorite tall-Track Stamina Bottom in Standard and Zero-G, yah, but not in Limited (I kind of
wish it was awesome in LTD too, but it hasn't worked at all for me so far).
Quote:Would it be alright to add (MF-L/MF-F) to the Stamina combos? Or ED145 to Meteo L-Drago? I know ED145 was up in the air but doesn't it perform basically as well as TR145?
I don't see much point in listing MF options for Stamina combos (I mean, maybe, but it seems kind of pointless to me).
I could see ED145 going up, yah. Are there tests for that anywhere?
Quote:Just for clarity's sake I separated Libra from Scythe and Duo on F230CF/GCF since you did the same for TH170/SR200CS. Also I strongly believe Burn F230CS deserves a spot.
Oh, good. I thought I had separated them. Whoopsy, haha.
Ehhh... maybe. I haven't looked at too much testing for it yet. I will later today, but as for now I don't know enough about to give you an opinion.