(Feb. 16, 2019 11:21 AM)Wombat Wrote: Please, for everyone's sake, can we just get rid of this ridiculous notion that Burst Classic must exclude all parts released after the Dual Layer era? I don't know why everyone is so violently opposed to allowing Turbo, or Dash Drivers, or God Layers, you do realize that if we had only the Single and Dual Layer parts, the Burst Classic meta would be the same as it was the first time around? With the metal removed from the Layers and the burst resistance nerfed due to the weak slopes, Hasbro's Turbo Layers (except Kerbeus K4, which is a weird outlier) are on a power tier much closer to the Single/Dual Layers than anything else, and I've actually had KJ do some tests that corroborate these results, so it stands to reason that they should be legal. Right now, the only reason that they're not is due to the fact that they're still currently in production and each new one would need to be evaluated on release (which would lead to a lot of rule updates). As for the new Hasbro Exclusive stuff like Dullahan and Ogre, those are parts we really don't have much information on, so we should get some testing on them before making a final decision, but given that their circumstances are very similar to both Turbo and the Hasbro exclusive Dual Layers I doubt they'll be a serious threat to the health of the Classic meta.
(Feb. 15, 2019 2:48 PM)ks123 Wrote: Yes. This is Burst Classic format, not Turbo format. Turbo layers is very strongs and Single and Dual layers defeat most Turbo layers.(Feb. 16, 2019 6:14 AM)ZYeYO Wrote: some of us want this where they are allowed but others say no because it gets rid of the whole classic name in The Format that's for me to begin with I did not like the name classic I just wanted a Limited Format whare we could just use single and dual layers and maybe some God layers
Turbo Format does not exist, but there is nothing stating that Burst Classic and Turbo need to be mutually exclusive. Burst Classic is only a name, functionally it is a Limited Format that's just balanced around the Single and Dual Layers. If some other part, regardless of what brand or series its from, can exist in the format without overcentralizing the meta, then there is no reason that it should be banned. It's really, really disappointing that this is something that needs to be repeated.
People are opposed to parts from later Burst series being included in a format entitled "Burst Classic" because it's built on a false premise. The logic behind this format's title seems to come from its banning of most non-Basic and Dual Layers and all new Discs following the end of the Dual Layer System.
However, the same logic fails to be applied for Drivers; instead, a logic more akin to that of MFB Limited part bans is used. The resulting confusion sprung from this contradiction is evidenced by the recurring calls for the banning or unbanning of various Turbo parts on less than consistently stable grounds.
If the function of this format is that of a Limited class, then it ought to be called just that: Burst Limited. Changing the name of the format to reflect what it is in function should immediately end all debate over what parts ought be legal or illegal based on their release dates or whatever "Classic" is supposed to mean...