RDF has stamina only slightly better than RS, and is not aggressive enough to be anywhere near as good as RF/R2F/LRF. It's certainly more viable than RS, but it has very similar weaknesses.
I still prefer CS, because RDF still has too little stamina for any attacker with a well distributed wheel/passable stamina and an RS/RSF-like weakness to left spin (maybe not quite as pronounced, but still not good). It's an awesome defense tip, but to even suggest it as having stamina is laughable, and you're severely overestimating it's attack abilities, in a metagame where things like Variares and Blitz need all the speed they can get to succeed
Currently, everything except RF, LRF, and R2F should probably be removed from tier 1 attack and dropped to tier 2, s there are not currently any viable attack combo's which use them. CS also needs a note stating that this only applies to very aggressive ones, but generally RF is simply a far more reliable choice. F and HF can move to Tier 3, WF should remain, it's roughly on par with or better than MF, the only reason it was less popular was rarity and scraping on BD145. RDF could probably sit comfortably in Tier 2, as well.
You could create a Tier Four, even, for SF, JB, WB, FS, F: D, and maybe LF (though that could even go a tier below, it is so utterly horrid).
Oh, as for stamina: W2D and EWD should be added to tier 2. They're very similar to WD, but generally WD is preferred, and it's not like a significant amount of new testing will be done on them any time soon
Man, I hope Mercury gets an unpainted release, knowing so little about it bugs me.
Nightmare can go in Tier 2 defense, it's roughly on par with Earth, maybe slightly worse, but I'd use it over Grand any day.
Also, Ultrablader, if you want me to do this all up in a draft of the list to save you working through it all, just give me a yell. I would do it anyway, but this is your thing and I don't want to step on any toes.
I still prefer CS, because RDF still has too little stamina for any attacker with a well distributed wheel/passable stamina and an RS/RSF-like weakness to left spin (maybe not quite as pronounced, but still not good). It's an awesome defense tip, but to even suggest it as having stamina is laughable, and you're severely overestimating it's attack abilities, in a metagame where things like Variares and Blitz need all the speed they can get to succeed
Currently, everything except RF, LRF, and R2F should probably be removed from tier 1 attack and dropped to tier 2, s there are not currently any viable attack combo's which use them. CS also needs a note stating that this only applies to very aggressive ones, but generally RF is simply a far more reliable choice. F and HF can move to Tier 3, WF should remain, it's roughly on par with or better than MF, the only reason it was less popular was rarity and scraping on BD145. RDF could probably sit comfortably in Tier 2, as well.
You could create a Tier Four, even, for SF, JB, WB, FS, F: D, and maybe LF (though that could even go a tier below, it is so utterly horrid).
Oh, as for stamina: W2D and EWD should be added to tier 2. They're very similar to WD, but generally WD is preferred, and it's not like a significant amount of new testing will be done on them any time soon
Man, I hope Mercury gets an unpainted release, knowing so little about it bugs me.
Nightmare can go in Tier 2 defense, it's roughly on par with Earth, maybe slightly worse, but I'd use it over Grand any day.
Also, Ultrablader, if you want me to do this all up in a draft of the list to save you working through it all, just give me a yell. I would do it anyway, but this is your thing and I don't want to step on any toes.