After some players assumed that Hunter-S might be superior to Hunter, I decided to do some tests. As attacking bey I chose Xcalius X3, because it is in my opinion still the strongest attack type layer Hasbro has to offer. I chose the combo X3.7M which kjrules17 already used in some of his tests.
Opponents from easy to hard: Satomb S3, Engaard E4, Roktavor R3, Tide Treptune T3, Hercules H4
Stamina / Defense bey first, attack type second. Alternating between banking and angled shoots for attacking bey.
X3.7M.Hn vs. S3.2G.Lp
X3.7M.Hn-S vs. S3.2G.Lp
X3.7M.Hn vs. E4.Ω.Qs-S (with Level chip)
X3.7M.Hn-S vs. E4.Ω.Qs-S (with Level chip)
X3.7M.Hn vs. R3.4C.Fl
X3.7M.Hn-S vs. R3.4C.Fl
X3.7M.Hn vs. T3.8B.E
X3.7M.Hn-S vs. T3.8B.E
X3.7M.Hn vs. H4.13.Et-S (with Level chip)
X3.7M.Hn-S vs. H4.13.Et-S (with Level chip)
Overall Hn vs. Hn-S: 28:21 wins.
Conclusion
Here You see that Hn-S' diameter is twice Hn's diameter. Xtreme's diameter lies in between. I would say Hunter > Xtreme > Hunter-S because of control and stamina. But the comparison with Xtreme still has to be tested.
Opponents from easy to hard: Satomb S3, Engaard E4, Roktavor R3, Tide Treptune T3, Hercules H4
Stamina / Defense bey first, attack type second. Alternating between banking and angled shoots for attacking bey.
X3.7M.Hn vs. S3.2G.Lp
Spoiler (Click to View)
Spoiler (Click to View)
Spoiler (Click to View)
Spoiler (Click to View)
Spoiler (Click to View)
Spoiler (Click to View)
Spoiler (Click to View)
Spoiler (Click to View)
Spoiler (Click to View)
Spoiler (Click to View)
Overall Hn vs. Hn-S: 28:21 wins.
Conclusion
Spoiler (Click to View)
Here You see that Hn-S' diameter is twice Hn's diameter. Xtreme's diameter lies in between. I would say Hunter > Xtreme > Hunter-S because of control and stamina. But the comparison with Xtreme still has to be tested.