Entry 1 the background makes the character stand out, and has a nice feel and the blending of the brushes seem good, it also seems as if shes in a spot light. But there is some random block of black on the far right side of the tag.
Entry 2 the background seems completely random at first, but after looking at it for a few minutes, you seem to see more stuff looks as if there is a water fall, and a river with a tree bending over it... Naruto seems slightly pixelated and doesn't seem to go with the background, I don't really like the text in this tag...
My vote goes for Entry 1.