Equipment/Test Details (Click to View)
Zero-G Attack Stadium
MSF-L Genbull Dragoon F230GCF vs. MSF Killerken Dragooon B:D
MSF-L Genbull Dragoon F230GCF: 8 wins (All KO)
MSF Killerken Dragooon B:D: 2 wins (2 KO)
Dragooon F230GCF win rate: 80%
Should have been 10-0 for F230GCF due to some poor launches by me, but I think it’s important to consider this aspect as well. In some ways, your argument is dissonant with itself; you talk about how apparently easy it is for someone to walk into a tournament and sweep it with F230CF/GCF (I don’t doubt that it’s possible), yet then you go on to talk about all of these launch techniques that are needed to be successful against certain match ups. Clearly, it isn’t as simple as you are suggesting in certain parts of your case.
MSF-L Genbull Dragoon F230GCF vs. MSF Killerken Dragooon SA165BWD
MSF-L Genbull Dragoon F230GCF: 0 wins
MSF Killerken Dragooon SA165BWD: 10 wins (All OS)
Dragooon F230GCF win rate: 0%
Zero-G Balance Stadium
MSF-L Genbull Dragoon F230GCF vs. MSF Killerken Dragooon B:D
MSF-L Genbull Dragoon F230GCF: 8 wins (6 KO, 2 OS)
MSF Killerken Dragooon B:D: 0 wins
2 Draws
Dragooon F230GCF win rate: 100%
MSF-L Genbull Dragoon F230GCF vs. MSF Killerken Dragooon SA165BWD
MSF-L Genbull Dragoon F230GCF: 0 wins
MSF Killerken Dragooon SA165BWD: 10 wins (All OS)
Dragooon F230GCF win rate: 0%
Zero-G Defense Stadium
MSF-L Genbull Dragoon F230GCF vs. MSF Killerken Dragooon B:D
MSF-L Genbull Dragoon F230GCF: 5 wins (4 KO, 1 OS)
MSF Killerken Dragooon B:D: 4 wins (3 OS, 1 KO)
1 Draw
Dragooon F230GCF win rate: 50%
MSF-L Genbull Dragoon F230GCF vs. MSF Killerken Dragooon SA165BWD
MSF-L Genbull Dragoon F230GCF: 0 wins
MSF Killerken Dragooon SA165BWD: 10 wins (All OS)
Dragooon F230GCF win rate: 0%
B:D got destroyed, but in looking at these results it should be obvious that it became progressively more difficult for F230CF/GCF to win as I moved from the Attack Stadium (where it should have won 10-0), to Balance, and then finally the Defense Stadium. In the Defense stadium if you aren’t able to move B:D from the large, flat stamina area in the middle for whatever reason, you will most likely lose unless F230CF/GCF or B:D is at an angle where it becomes possible to destabilize B:D. It’s not a lost cause in that stadium, but the match up isn’t as much of a home run for F230CF/GCF in that stadium as it is in Attack/Balance where it can KO or at the very least, sway it violently enough to drain its Stamina. This stadium proves that B:D straight up has more Stamina than F230CF/GCF when sway is not always a factor. I don’t know about other areas like North Carolina, but in Toronto all three stadiums are in regular rotation at every Zero-G Format tournament, so for us, it’s an important factor to consider and one that I don’t think should be excluded from this discussion as it seems to have been so far. All three are legal, remember.
As for SA165BWD, maybe now you’ll understand why F230CF/GCF isn’t the game breaker that it seems to be in North Carolina. The results fairly accurately represent what happens in Toronto tournaments with this match up. There’s no contest, usually. What I don’t understand is why your results are so drastically different. I watched your video and in comparison, my custom/BWD doesn’t move nearly as much and seems to have much better balance than yours, for some reason.
It’s also worth mentioning my use of MSF on B:D/SA165BWD. I don’t have any results to back this up so I could be wrong, but in match ups like these (and for Zero-G in general, I guess), I feel that additional weight is important for all types to either a) Increase your sway power or b) Increase your resistance to sway. Maybe this made a difference.
Finally, I think it's also important to consider right-spin SA165TB's performance against right-spin F230CF/GCF while we are determining whether or not F230CF/GCF is truly deserving of being banned. Right-spin SA165TB has an easier time against right-spin F230CF/GCF than left-spin variants do against left-spin F230CF/GCF, for some reason. TheBlackDragon posted about this a while ago here: http://worldbeyblade.org/Thread-Why-F230...pid1168106 I haven't tested left-spin SA165TB myself so perhaps my results would also be different, but we all should be aware that there may be more options for dealing with right-spin F230CF/GCF than left-spin F230CF/GCF.