Entry 1 : the quality of the images is good , but like most said bad editing , it actually looks like a banner o some naruto fan sites than a sig
Entry 2 : Looks like a sig but i really feel the naruto logo shouldn't be there , but the blur kinda gives it a sig like feel
Both have a massive amount of error for improvement , but my vote for this one will go for Entry 2
Again being a huge epic naruto fan i am really disappointed that this topic could have really made some awesome looking sigs
I Would say don't make sigs to impress others , make them in such a way that you feel impressed & really feel proud of your work