In the initial testing that I did with Odin (just messing around with different combos, 4-5 rounds at a time), it seemed to me like it was pretty poor for attack, but really good for stamina, so I decided to test that theory and see how it stacked up against the reigning stamina layer, Deathscyther.
Please feel free to post your tests and thoughts below as well.
Equipment
Procedure
Odin Heavy Accel vs. Wyvern Heavy Accel
Odin Heavy Accel: 14 wins (2 BF, 1 KO, 11 SF)
Wyvern Heavy Accel: 6 wins (3 BF, 1 KO, 2 SF)
1 draw (DSF)
Odin win percentage: 70%
Average clicks lost per round:
Odin: 1.1
Wyvern: 1
Round by Round
Definitely better than Wyvern at mobile defense (one on one anyway), but so is Deathscyther, so who cares.
Odin Spread Accel vs. Deathscyther Spread Accel
Odin Spread Accel: 12 wins (1 BF, 11 SF)
Deathscyther Spread Accel: 8 wins (3 BF, 5 SF)
1 draw (DSF)
Odin win percentage: 60%
Average clicks lost per round:
Odin: 1.6
Deathscyther: 0.85
Round by Round
Odin Spread Survive vs. Deathscyther Spread Survive
Odin Spread Survive: 11 wins (3 BF, 8 SF)
Deathscyther Spread Survive: 9 wins (All SF)
3 draws (1 DBF, 2 DSF)
Odin win percentage: 55%
Average clicks lost per round:
Odin: 1
Deathscyther: 1.2
Round by Round
These two tests seem too close to call, but, for me it was very apparent that Odin spins for just a little bit longer than Deathscyther. The difference is so small though, that the order of launch will determine who wins. Both of the DSF draws were when Odin was launched first. The only real question left at all, for me, is if Odin will burst easier than Deathscyther and, at least in this one on one matchup, it was Odin who bursted Deathscyther. Odin also seems to stand up a bit better to VHA and SHA, but I haven't done any official tests for that yet.
Odin Spread Survive vs. Valkyrie Spread Survive
Odin Spread Survive: 12 wins (All BF)
Valkyrie Spread Survive: 8 wins (All BF)
10 draws (All DBF)
Odin win percentage: 60%
Average clicks lost per round:
Odin: 3.2
Valkyrie: 3.2
Round by Round
This test, to me, seemed to show that Odin was better than Deathscyther vs VSS, but I was using a moderately worn Valkyrie layer, so it is hard to say for sure, when this match-up is all about bursting. Once I decide to break out another Valkyrie, I will surely retest this with it.
Part 2: Testing with a brand-new Valkyrie
Odin Spread Survive vs. Valkyrie Spread Survive
Odin Spread Survive: 10 wins (7 BF, 2 KO, 1 SF)
Valkyrie Spread Survive: 10 wins (All BF)
8 draws (All DBF)
Odin win percentage: 50%
Average clicks lost per round:
Odin: 3.35
Valkyrie: 2.75
Round by Round
Valkyrie held up a little better this time, but Odin still seems to be better than Deathscyther in this situation. It is a test with a lot of bursts and a lot of variables though, so it is hard to say for sure without tests from others. Any other tests that you guys could do on this matchup especially, would be greatly appreciated.
Now, because of suggestions from people made in this thread, I decided to actually test this mobile defense combo in action, against Valkyrie Heavy Accel (with that same brand new Valkyrie) to make sure there were no confounding variables and that A + B does, in fact, equal C.
*BENCHMARK*
Wyvern Spread Accel vs. Valkyrie Heavy Accel
Wyvern Spread Accel: 20 wins (1 BF, 19 SF)
Valkyrie Heavy Accel: 0 wins (All BF)
0 draws
Wyvern win percentage: 100%
Average clicks lost per round:
Wyvern: 0.75
Valkyrie: 0.55
Round by Round
*BENCHMARK*
Deathscyther Spread Accel vs. Valkyrie Heavy Accel
Deathscyther Spread Accel: 16 wins (4 BF, 12 SF)
Valkyrie Heavy Accel: 4 wins (3 BF, 1 KO)
3 draws (All DBF)
Deathscyther win percentage: 80%
Average clicks lost per round:
Deathscyther: 1.7
Valkyrie: 1.65
Round by Round
Odin Spread Accel vs. Valkyrie Spread Accel
Odin Spread Accel: 16 wins (4 BF, 2 KO, 10 SF)
Valkyrie Spread Accel: 4 wins (2 BF, 1 KO, 1 SF)
1 draw (DBF)
Odin win percentage: 80%
Average clicks lost per round:
Odin: 1.25
Valkyrie: 1.85
Round by Round
So it seems that it does do just as well as Deathscyther, against Valkyrie. Wyvern obviously does even better, but doesn't spin as long. It really isn't about which one does better against Valkyrie, unless you are positive your opponent will pick it (which you almost never can know). It is about being able to beat Valkyrie well, but also do the best possible against all other combos as well, in case your opponent chooses differently. With Odin spinning just a little bit longer than Deathscyther and being able to take hits a little bit better as well, my opinion is that Odin would be the best choice for mobile defense, unless you are 100% certain that your opponent will choose VHA, because you will beat VHA anyway and stand a better chance against other combos as well.
I decided to test what was better for mobile defense, Odin Heavy Accel, or Odin Spread Accel. We all know that Heavy is the best disk to use with the Defense driver, but what about Accel, is it the same?
Odin Heavy Accel vs. Odin Spread Accel
Odin Heavy Accel: 14 wins (3 BF, 1 KO, 10 SF)
Odin Spread Accel: 6 wins (All SF)
3 drawa (All DSF)
Odin Heavy win percentage: 70%
Average clicks lost per round:
Odin Heavy: 0.55
Odin Spread: 1.3
Round by Round
It seems that Heavy is better for mobile as well as immobile defense
Please feel free to post your tests and thoughts below as well.
Equipment
Spoiler (Click to View)
Procedure
Spoiler (Click to View)
Odin Heavy Accel vs. Wyvern Heavy Accel
Odin Heavy Accel: 14 wins (2 BF, 1 KO, 11 SF)
Wyvern Heavy Accel: 6 wins (3 BF, 1 KO, 2 SF)
1 draw (DSF)
Odin win percentage: 70%
Average clicks lost per round:
Odin: 1.1
Wyvern: 1
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)
Definitely better than Wyvern at mobile defense (one on one anyway), but so is Deathscyther, so who cares.
Odin Spread Accel vs. Deathscyther Spread Accel
Odin Spread Accel: 12 wins (1 BF, 11 SF)
Deathscyther Spread Accel: 8 wins (3 BF, 5 SF)
1 draw (DSF)
Odin win percentage: 60%
Average clicks lost per round:
Odin: 1.6
Deathscyther: 0.85
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)
Odin Spread Survive vs. Deathscyther Spread Survive
Odin Spread Survive: 11 wins (3 BF, 8 SF)
Deathscyther Spread Survive: 9 wins (All SF)
3 draws (1 DBF, 2 DSF)
Odin win percentage: 55%
Average clicks lost per round:
Odin: 1
Deathscyther: 1.2
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)
These two tests seem too close to call, but, for me it was very apparent that Odin spins for just a little bit longer than Deathscyther. The difference is so small though, that the order of launch will determine who wins. Both of the DSF draws were when Odin was launched first. The only real question left at all, for me, is if Odin will burst easier than Deathscyther and, at least in this one on one matchup, it was Odin who bursted Deathscyther. Odin also seems to stand up a bit better to VHA and SHA, but I haven't done any official tests for that yet.
Odin Spread Survive vs. Valkyrie Spread Survive
Odin Spread Survive: 12 wins (All BF)
Valkyrie Spread Survive: 8 wins (All BF)
10 draws (All DBF)
Odin win percentage: 60%
Average clicks lost per round:
Odin: 3.2
Valkyrie: 3.2
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)
This test, to me, seemed to show that Odin was better than Deathscyther vs VSS, but I was using a moderately worn Valkyrie layer, so it is hard to say for sure, when this match-up is all about bursting. Once I decide to break out another Valkyrie, I will surely retest this with it.
Part 2: Testing with a brand-new Valkyrie
Odin Spread Survive vs. Valkyrie Spread Survive
Odin Spread Survive: 10 wins (7 BF, 2 KO, 1 SF)
Valkyrie Spread Survive: 10 wins (All BF)
8 draws (All DBF)
Odin win percentage: 50%
Average clicks lost per round:
Odin: 3.35
Valkyrie: 2.75
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)
Valkyrie held up a little better this time, but Odin still seems to be better than Deathscyther in this situation. It is a test with a lot of bursts and a lot of variables though, so it is hard to say for sure without tests from others. Any other tests that you guys could do on this matchup especially, would be greatly appreciated.
Now, because of suggestions from people made in this thread, I decided to actually test this mobile defense combo in action, against Valkyrie Heavy Accel (with that same brand new Valkyrie) to make sure there were no confounding variables and that A + B does, in fact, equal C.
*BENCHMARK*
Wyvern Spread Accel vs. Valkyrie Heavy Accel
Wyvern Spread Accel: 20 wins (1 BF, 19 SF)
Valkyrie Heavy Accel: 0 wins (All BF)
0 draws
Wyvern win percentage: 100%
Average clicks lost per round:
Wyvern: 0.75
Valkyrie: 0.55
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)
*BENCHMARK*
Deathscyther Spread Accel vs. Valkyrie Heavy Accel
Deathscyther Spread Accel: 16 wins (4 BF, 12 SF)
Valkyrie Heavy Accel: 4 wins (3 BF, 1 KO)
3 draws (All DBF)
Deathscyther win percentage: 80%
Average clicks lost per round:
Deathscyther: 1.7
Valkyrie: 1.65
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)
Odin Spread Accel vs. Valkyrie Spread Accel
Odin Spread Accel: 16 wins (4 BF, 2 KO, 10 SF)
Valkyrie Spread Accel: 4 wins (2 BF, 1 KO, 1 SF)
1 draw (DBF)
Odin win percentage: 80%
Average clicks lost per round:
Odin: 1.25
Valkyrie: 1.85
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)
So it seems that it does do just as well as Deathscyther, against Valkyrie. Wyvern obviously does even better, but doesn't spin as long. It really isn't about which one does better against Valkyrie, unless you are positive your opponent will pick it (which you almost never can know). It is about being able to beat Valkyrie well, but also do the best possible against all other combos as well, in case your opponent chooses differently. With Odin spinning just a little bit longer than Deathscyther and being able to take hits a little bit better as well, my opinion is that Odin would be the best choice for mobile defense, unless you are 100% certain that your opponent will choose VHA, because you will beat VHA anyway and stand a better chance against other combos as well.
I decided to test what was better for mobile defense, Odin Heavy Accel, or Odin Spread Accel. We all know that Heavy is the best disk to use with the Defense driver, but what about Accel, is it the same?
Odin Heavy Accel vs. Odin Spread Accel
Odin Heavy Accel: 14 wins (3 BF, 1 KO, 10 SF)
Odin Spread Accel: 6 wins (All SF)
3 drawa (All DSF)
Odin Heavy win percentage: 70%
Average clicks lost per round:
Odin Heavy: 0.55
Odin Spread: 1.3
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)