World Beyblade Organization by Fighting Spirits Inc. Off-Topic Forums Your Creations

GFX Tournament Round 2: Xyo vs. BP

Sep. 24, 2011  11:35 AM
 
~Full Metal Alchemist

Entry 1
[Image: di-7W8W.png]
Entry 2
[Image: di-QN03.png]

VOTE~
Sep. 24, 2011  11:38 AM
 
i vote for entry 1 entry 2 doesn't match the baground it should be of diffrent colour and entry 1 is graphically better than entry 2 i vote for entry 1
Sep. 24, 2011  11:55 AM
 
(Sep. 24, 2011  11:38 AM)BEYBOOST Wrote: i vote for entry 1 entry 2 doesn't match the baground it should be of diffrent colour and entry 1 is graphically better than entry 2 i vote for entry 1

are you sure you didn't get the entries the wrong way around?

the render on entry 1 is not as good, it has not been blended well, and it seems like the background doesn't really relate to the render. however there is one main focal point.

entry 2 has a matching colour scheme, and seems better blended, however it doesn't really stand out as much, render wise.

I vote entry 2
Sep. 24, 2011  11:56 AM
 
entry 2

I voted for this because it is graphically better than entry 1. It is blended well, flow is good, and texture.

Entry 1 however, is also good. however I can't feel the voting power in it
Sep. 24, 2011  12:01 PM
 
Ha....ha....I've been biting all my nails off figuring how the heck should I do my tag...now that it was done, I can resume typing..
Sep. 24, 2011  12:03 PM
 
I vote E2 as it feels as though the render is part of the BG while on the other hand E1 is also really good but falls short by a small margin
Sep. 24, 2011  12:22 PM
 
i vote for entry 2 as its bg is bettere
Sep. 24, 2011  12:38 PM
 
My vote goes to entry 2! I like the blending better!
Sep. 24, 2011  12:50 PM
 
Score Check:
E1: 1
E2: 5
Sep. 24, 2011  1:02 PM
 
Its ok ill catchup with the votes Uncertain
Sep. 24, 2011  1:10 PM
 
I forgot:

anyone notice they have the same flow and placement o.o
Sep. 24, 2011  1:17 PM
 
Thats what I am saying what a coincidence
Oh and I vote for entry one because it flows and sytiuytuyto
Sep. 24, 2011  1:48 PM
 
I still have hope Grin i could still win but your tag is really good
Sep. 24, 2011  1:57 PM
 
I vote Entry 2. Better blending.

EDIT: Entry 2 has matching color scheme and a better flow than first entry.
Sep. 24, 2011  2:04 PM
 
Please explain more instead of just a minor one like blending
Sep. 24, 2011  2:07 PM
 
I vote Entry 1 because the BG in Entry 1 looks better and in Entry 2 part of the guys hair is blended away and that doesn't look appealing.
Sep. 24, 2011  2:23 PM
 
I vote entry one, there is a nice focal point and the render doesn't dissapear into the bg.

Also isn't the point of having annonymous entries to disable biased votes? If so, why are you guys (Xyo, BP) talking in such a way that reveals which entry is yours?
Sep. 24, 2011  2:26 PM
 
They just try not to reveal anything , however they fail at doing that Uncertain
Sep. 24, 2011  2:35 PM
 
What-?! It is Xyo not me. Uncertain I have no intention of revealing which is mine.
Sep. 24, 2011  3:08 PM
 
This makes me angry.....lol
I really think that entry one fits Full Metal better than entry two. But it is not as graphically good as entry two. The artist who created entry two needs to watch some Full Metal.....
It is really good, but, Full Metal is a very "dark" series, imo. Alchemy is not going into the light, lol. Ed might by the protagonist, but the stuff that goes on isn't, nice, i guess.
My vote goes to entry two.
Sep. 24, 2011  3:11 PM
 
(Sep. 24, 2011  3:08 PM)othellog Wrote: This makes me angry.....lol
I really think that entry one fits Full Metal better than entry two. But it is not as graphically good as entry two. The artist who created entry two needs to watch some Full Metal.....
It is really good, but, Full Metal is a very "dark" series, imo. Alchemy is not going into the light, lol. Ed might by the protagonist, but the stuff that goes on isn't, nice, i guess.
My vote goes to entry two.

Yeah. Especially the first series. So, my vote goes to Entry 1. The colors is Entry 2 are too bright, and there are random blue lines that just don't fit.
Sep. 24, 2011  3:27 PM
 
(Sep. 24, 2011  3:11 PM)NoodooSoup Wrote:
(Sep. 24, 2011  3:08 PM)othellog Wrote: This makes me angry.....lol
I really think that entry one fits Full Metal better than entry two. But it is not as graphically good as entry two. The artist who created entry two needs to watch some Full Metal.....
It is really good, but, Full Metal is a very "dark" series, imo. Alchemy is not going into the light, lol. Ed might by the protagonist, but the stuff that goes on isn't, nice, i guess.
My vote goes to entry two.

Yeah. Especially the first series. So, my vote goes to Entry 2. The colors is Entry 1 are too bright, and there are random blue lines that just don't fit.
Um...Aren't you wrong? Entry 1 certainly doesn't have blue lines..Uncertain
Sep. 24, 2011  3:32 PM
 
Woops, yes I am. I am extremely sorry for my mistake.
Sep. 24, 2011  3:39 PM
 
Score check:
E1: 5
E2: 7

VOTE!
Sep. 25, 2011  5:21 AM
 
Bump. Please vote people.
Page 1
Next