Round 2 GFX Battle: Electric Vs Fyuuor

Round 2 GFX Battle: Electric Vs Fyuuor


[Image: electricvsfyuuor.jpg]

Theme: One Piece

ENTRY 1
[Image: zoro3o.jpg]


ENTRY 2
[Image: CxYb9.png]


Tally of Votes:

Entry 1: 17 Votes
Entry 2: 24 Votes

*Voting Closes on the 22nd of July*
I Vote Entry 2
I vote for entry 1.

Background fits the render , text is nice although the placement of text is not good. The same goes for render placement although the colors do match IMO. Effects are actually good.
Entry 2! The nice blend of a cool poster.
Entry 1. Nice renders and editing. And it matches all well, but no too well. ANd some of the placements are A BIT of, but fine.
Entry 1 because it looks cool.
Entry 1. Don't get me wrong, they're both AWESOME, but entry 1 appeals to me more.
Libruhhh

Entry 2-Good text placement and not too hard to look at.
1 there is just something that draws me in
1 is my choice I don't know why it just is.
Entry #1. It seems more hardcore if you know what I mean.
Votes:
Entry 1: 7 Votes
Entry 2: 3 Votes
I have not watched a lot of One Piece, but the second entry seems to bring the essence and the spirit of Once Piece more. The shows seems to be quite colourful and 'funky'.
(Jul. 15, 2011  8:08 PM)Kai-V Wrote: I have not watched a lot of One Piece, but the second entry seems to bring the essence and the spirit of Once Piece more. The shows seems to be quite colourful and 'funky'.

So your vote is for 2?
(Jul. 15, 2011  9:27 PM)Taiwo Seigi Wrote: So your vote is for 2?

Yes, it is.
The "Zoro" text in the second one kinda puts me off, so I pick Entry 1. They are both so amazing, both Electric and Fyuuor did a nice job.
Wow, amazing entries! Good effort shown by Electric and Fyuuor, but if I were to pick, I would go for Entry 1. But my decision was very sharp, and the decision was very close to me.
Votes:
Entry 1: 9 votes
Entry 2: 5 votes
i would vote for 2 i know 1 is cool looking and nicely done but according to me 2nd satisfies the theme the most
Oh, Round 2 has started. I thought there would be a longer voting period... good luck guys, though!
Voting for #2, with the reasons pretty much identical to Kai-V's.

One Piece's art style reminds me of Rave Master/Groove Adventure Rave's, which seemed more silly than serious; #2 fits the silliness more.

If it was a different theme like Tekken/Mortal Kombat, #1 would have got my vote due to the shiny/C4D/abstract effects in there simulating a special attack. But, the theme is One Piece, and has to have a different "approach".
Entry #2 im a fan of One Piece and it is more appealing to people who watch it and my reason is like Kai-V's
Nice entry Electric.

To be honest I found this theme a little difficult in trying to find a decent image to use Uncertain
Looks like we're both Roronoa Zoro fans, huh ?
I don't really watch One Peice, but I found Roronoa Zoro the coolest.

Anyway, You're entry is amazing.
I always looked forward to our battle, Thanks for teaching me you're amazing tricks, they're coming in handy right now.