Random Beyblade Anime and Manga Thoughts

(Dec. 08, 2020  12:39 AM)Admiral W Wrote:
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:37 AM)EarthHelios Wrote: But I thought you liked Season 1 and 2

That's why I said for the most part. Season 1 and 2 are the exception. Season 1 stayed pretty close to the manga and therefore was superb, season 2 differed a bit but was still a truly excellent season.

season 1 and 2 are really good
How I would put it in for all the seasons: Good, In the middle, Bad
2000: In the middle
V-Force: Bad
G-revolution: Good
Metal Fusion: In The Middle
Metal Masters: Good
Metal Fury: Good
Shogun Steel: Bad
Burst S1: Good
Evolution: Good
Turbo: Bad
Rise: Good
Surge: In The Middle
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:40 AM)Eclipse Force Wrote: The occasional filler isn’t bad, but complete deviation from the story line makes problems imo.

Agreed. For example, I like the explanation and use of Wing Whip better in the anime than the manga. It's when they take the story itself in a completely different direction from the manga, that it suffers for the most part.
Imagine if we got the Delta chapter animated in Surge, or the Drago Valtryek arc where Valt visits the Victories, make a bey with Dante, and battles Dante.
Wait did Valt lose in the manga to Drago Valtryek?
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:44 AM)EarthHelios Wrote: Wait did Valt lose in the manga to Drago Valtryek?

Drago Valtryek jumped up and hit Sword head on with judgment from the top. Kinda hard to not lose to that.
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:45 AM)Eclipse Force Wrote:
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:44 AM)EarthHelios Wrote: Wait did Valt lose in the manga to Drago Valtryek?

Drago Valtryek, jumped up and hit Sword head on with judgment from the top. Kinda hard to not lose to that.

Heat Salamander 2.0 in here
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:40 AM)Eclipse Force Wrote: The occasional filler isn’t bad, but complete deviation from the story line makes problems imo.

yea fillers can be good but can mess up the story overall.  one of the examples is naruto had loads if fillers to the point you fall asleep something boruto inhereted , the same happen with bleach although the bleach ones were actually good one rares time where the filler is very good . Tokyo ghoul also suffered this with s2 they went completely opposite to the manga and didn't end well.  world trigger tried that carp to instead of stopping and wait for the manga to reach further (thank God s2 is coming and their fixing this mess)
One of the details I love from the Rise/GT manga is the explanation of the senior and junior division of the blading league. Would have loved to have had that introduced In the anime. Valt was world champion of the senior division and overall champ while Aiger was junior division champ.
Anime has different writer from the manga hence why many different things occur
They really need to fix what they did in Legends Festival
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:46 AM)Admiral W Wrote: One of the details I love from the Rise/GT manga is the explanation of the senior and junior division of the blading league. Would have loved to have had that introduced In the anime. Valt was world champion of the senior division and overall champ while Aiger was junior division champ.

That’s a perfect way to establish Aiger and Valt in large roles yet make it so they aren’t exactly the same level.
I can see how they will play out the Tag Team League
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:46 AM)Needforspeed Wrote: Anime has different writer from the manga hence why many different things occur

We know. That's basically what were saying. It would be better if they did a straight adaptation of the manga instead of sticking with the stories the anime writers wrote.
Oh boy watch Aiga and Ranjiro get last place.
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:49 AM)Admiral W Wrote:
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:46 AM)Needforspeed Wrote: Anime has different writer from the manga hence why many different things occur

We know. That's basically what were saying. It would be better if they did a straight adaptation of the manga instead of sticking with the stories the anime writers wrote.

Imagine spending more money to hire an anime writer when you don’t need one.
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:47 AM)Eclipse Force Wrote:
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:46 AM)Admiral W Wrote: One of the details I love from the Rise/GT manga is the explanation of the senior and junior division of the blading league. Would have loved to have had that introduced In the anime. Valt was world champion of the senior division and overall champ while Aiger was junior division champ.

That’s a perfect way to establish Aiger and Valt in large roles yet make it so they aren’t exactly the same level.

Yes indeed. They could have had their cake and ate it too.

(Dec. 08, 2020  12:50 AM)Eclipse Force Wrote:
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:49 AM)Admiral W Wrote: We know. That's basically what were saying. It would be better if they did a straight adaptation of the manga instead of sticking with the stories the anime writers wrote.

Imagine spending more money to hire an anime writer when you don’t need one.

Talk about a money saver.
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:49 AM)Admiral W Wrote:
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:46 AM)Needforspeed Wrote: Anime has different writer from the manga hence why many different things occur

We know. That's basically what were saying. It would be better if they did a straight adaptation of the manga instead of sticking with the stories the anime writers wrote.
Tbh It'd very hard bc hiro morita has 0 involvement or control in the anime so most likely just going to follow the previous trend where they don't explain the ranking and things like that
On the topic of Aiger, having him beat Valt in the end with a stamina finish is much better than a Burst imo.
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:50 AM)Eclipse Force Wrote:
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:49 AM)Admiral W Wrote: We know. That's basically what were saying. It would be better if they did a straight adaptation of the manga instead of sticking with the stories the anime writers wrote.

Imagine spending more money to hire an anime writer when you don’t need one.

never understood that with beyblade theirs loads of anime that fellows the manga or light novel just copy it and done even when the add a little extra it doesn't ruin the story (some does but rarely)
Lui and Drum: Tempest Upper
Shu and Lane: The End Counter
Aiga and Ranjiro: Infinite Tornado
Valt and Rantaro: Glide Sword
Hikaru and Hyuga: Double Smash
Sisco and Free: Mirage Drift
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:51 AM)Eclipse Force Wrote: On the topic of Aiger, having him beat Valt in the end with a stamina finish is much better than a Burst imo.
Yes indeed. Much easier to swallow.
I honestly wanna see a Lui vs. Free rematch
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:54 AM)Admiral W Wrote:
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:51 AM)Eclipse Force Wrote: On the topic of Aiger, having him beat Valt in the end with a stamina finish is much better than a Burst imo.
Yes indeed. Much easier to swallow.

What? No that’s not why it’s better lol. It’s better because it’s far more dramatic and climactic.
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:54 AM)Admiral W Wrote:
(Dec. 08, 2020  12:51 AM)Eclipse Force Wrote: On the topic of Aiger, having him beat Valt in the end with a stamina finish is much better than a Burst imo.
Yes indeed. Much easier to swallow.

Also Evolution wears down making it speed up which uses more stamina, so it has less stamina overall. It makes sense that way.