Proposal, bring a new rule for no contact self ko

Poll: Thoughts?

Yes, the scoring of no contact matches should be banned.
70.00%
21
No, the scoring of no contact matches should continue.
30.00%
9
Total: 100% 30 vote(s)
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:40 PM)Shindog Wrote:
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:38 PM)6Jupiter5 Wrote: 3 times each round. I would also be totally cool with 2 times each round.
I believe this was discussed in the Gatryaki thread as well. 
I believe 2 times each round was discussed at least a couple of time in the Gattyaki thread

So do you think the rule will be in place or should we should wait for more polling?
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:43 PM)6Jupiter5 Wrote:
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:40 PM)Shindog Wrote: I believe 2 times each round was discussed at least a couple of time in the Gattyaki thread

So do you think the rule will be in place or should we should wait for more polling?
Please read my updated response.  If air snipe exist, I will not support it personally.
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:43 PM)6Jupiter5 Wrote:
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:40 PM)Shindog Wrote: I believe 2 times each round was discussed at least a couple of time in the Gattyaki thread

So do you think the rule will be in place or should we should wait for more polling?

i think we should wait a bit longer to see
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:43 PM)beykid44 Wrote: and im not agreeing bc im their friend i just dont like that ule maybe 3 stirkes ur out? or 2

2 strikes and the opponent gets a point is fair.
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:45 PM)6Jupiter5 Wrote:
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:43 PM)beykid44 Wrote: and im not agreeing bc im their friend i just dont like that ule maybe 3 stirkes ur out? or 2

2 strikes and the opponent gets a point is fair.
Does the 2 strike rule include gattyaki air snipes?  Where you opponent is basically throwing Their bey to try to hit your bey in mid air?
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:48 PM)Shindog Wrote:
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:45 PM)6Jupiter5 Wrote: 2 strikes and the opponent gets a point is fair.
Does the 2 strike rule include gattyaki air snipes?  Where you opponent is basically throwing Their bey to try to hit your bey in mid air?

Nope.
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:50 PM)6Jupiter5 Wrote:
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:48 PM)Shindog Wrote: Does the 2 strike rule include gattyaki air snipes?  Where you opponent is basically throwing Their bey to try to hit your bey in mid air?

Nope.
Then how do you write this rule if gattyaki still exists?
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:48 PM)Shindog Wrote:
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:45 PM)6Jupiter5 Wrote: 2 strikes and the opponent gets a point is fair.
Does the 2 strike rule include gattyaki air snipes?  Where you opponent is basically throwing Their bey to try to hit your bey in mid air?

i don't think it should, that's almost like an intentional self KO
its technically not a self ko because you have been hit to be knocked out
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:51 PM)Orochi\s Blade Wrote:
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:48 PM)Shindog Wrote: Does the 2 strike rule include gattyaki air snipes?  Where you opponent is basically throwing Their bey to try to hit your bey in mid air?

i don't think it should, that's almost like an intentional self KO
I wouldn’t go as far as intentional but I would say it is a disregard for the risk of self KO.  If gattyaki air snipe or drop gattyaki remains in the game, I don’t know how to justify giving ppl multiple tries at it.
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:50 PM)Shindog Wrote:
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:50 PM)6Jupiter5 Wrote: Nope.
Then how do you write this rule if gattyaki still exists?

If a bey goes into a pocket without contact the player can force a redo (limited to two times), this disincludes failed attempts at sniping.

I noticed a flaw. If someone were to snipe how would we be able to tell?
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:55 PM)6Jupiter5 Wrote:
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:50 PM)Shindog Wrote: Then how do you write this rule if gattyaki still exists?

If a bey goes into a pocket without contact the player can force a redo (limited to two times), this disincludes failed attempts at sniping.

I noticed a flaw. If someone were to snipe how would we be able to tell?
I agree with your edit.
 
For anyone who hasn’t read the gattyaki thread here is the link:
https://worldbeyblade.org/Thread-Should-...pid1630991

The way I see it, if this topic matters to you then you should check out why I believe it is linked to gattyaki.
i got god tier eyes i can do well with that 6Jupiter5 Shindog
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:58 PM)beykid44 Wrote: i got god tier eyes i can do well with that 6Jupiter5 Shindog

While that’s good for you, not all people aren’t that fortunate.
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:58 PM)beykid44 Wrote: i got god tier eyes i can do well with that 6Jupiter5 Shindog

that would be great if you were a judge.




are you a judge?
(Nov. 01, 2020  11:21 PM)Orochi's Blade Wrote:
(Nov. 01, 2020  10:58 PM)beykid44 Wrote: i got god tier eyes i can do well with that 6Jupiter5 Shindog

that would be great if you were a judge.




are you a judge?

no but once i redo my quiz ill judge my own tournaments
Vote and express your thoughts please. Please look at the full conversation before making a descision for sure.
Can someone help me, i miss click the voting
(Nov. 02, 2020  6:43 AM)Needforspeed Wrote: Can someone help me, i miss click the voting

Unfortunately there is nothing that can be done.
Let me sum up the proposal

1. If a bey goes into a pocket without being touched, the player can force a redo

2. The redo is limited to 2 times each round of a battle

3. An attempt at sniping is not counted in this redo

4. This rule is in play during the first 8 seconds, any ko’s after 8 seconds will not be valid for a redo
(Nov. 01, 2020  9:50 PM)6Jupiter5 Wrote: I propose that we should bring a rule that stops the scoring of no contact matches in competitive play.

I agree. Its not fair at all

(Nov. 22, 2020  8:30 PM)6Jupiter5 Wrote: Let me sum up the proposal

1. If a bey goes into a pocket without being touched, the player can force a redo

2. The redo is limited to 2 times each round of a battle

3. An attempt at sniping is not counted in this redo

4. This rule is in play during the first 8 seconds, any ko’s after 8 seconds will not be valid for a redo

Agreed. That will work fine