(Jan. 09, 2012 11:28 PM)CRUelty Wrote: 'Sup guys.
I have a little something-something I would like to share to you all. If you don't like it, deal with it. I am taking all responsibilities and any harm (i.e. warnings and stuff) must go to me. If that doesn't give you a heads up about what is about to be written, click the spoiler.
When we didn't act like we were pro GFXers?
When we didn't strive to be the best?
When we didn't brag about going to a GFX school?
When we used to comment on signatures saying things like 'Cool background' or 'I like it a lot'?
Or how about when we didn't treat the General GFX thread like a GFX forum?
I believe the GFX thread and the GFXers here have fallen prey to some of these attempts to be a great GFXer, and they are trying to make the General GFX Thread as much like them as possible. The thing they struggle to realize is this;
This is not a GFX forum. This is a forum for Beyblades.
Things like this used to be cool (sorry to the maker of the sig for being publicized like this, it's just the first example that I found):
http://i54.tinypic.com/2h3t178.png
And are now things that get bashed on for being 'too mono' or whatever, and nowadays graphics focus a lot more on the effects, and not how the sig should feel. GFX needs meaning, otherwise it's just another rectangle.
These past few months (about 3-5) have been all about GFX tournaments, tutorials, GFX forums, and so much other carp that now people who are 'not up to skill' with people that claim themselves as awesome GFXers (you know who you are) try to make sigs out of their limits? I remember when GFX was a fun thing to do, seeing who could make their sig look the 'coolest' not the most 'professional'.
I don't see half of the signatures I see posted in the GFX thread as real GFX, but flashy rectangles with a ton of effects and random pictures and intricate images.
With these descriptions of the way I see things, you should figure out if you've been mentioned.
If you want this place to be so much like a GFX forum and just love the way they work, why bother ever using the WBO? I rarely see any of 'you' (again, you know who you are) make a legit beyblade-related post, but instead, instead of giving any praise (I understand the criticism you guys give, but ever think about, oh, I don't know, saying what you LIKE about the tag?)
I am aware I will receive flak for this post. If you don't like it, I accept your opinion. I accept all consequences that could follow. This is really just a really large thought I had one day.
I've highlighted everything that I don't exactly agree with and will confer what I feel needs to be pointed out.
This is not a GFX forum. This is a forum for Beyblades.
Just because this is a Beyblade forum, doesn't restrict it to be just the standard of the rest of the forum. This is the "Your Creations" section, and people have the right to post their creations and it shouldn't matter whether or not it's beyblade related.
And are now things that get bashed on for being 'too mono' or whatever, and nowadays graphics focus a lot more on the effects, and not how the sig should feel. GFX needs meaning, otherwise it's just another rectangle.
Not everybody is gonna like what someone posts, there will always be a different opinion. There is a difference between bashing and criticizing. Actually, I think that people think that criticisms are only negative, when really, a criticism is an evaluation one gives. "Too mono" is actually quite a good heads up. If someone tells you that your signature is mono, it's probably because it is, and having a signature that's "too mono" simply means that there's not enough colour and vibe going on, and has nothing to do with the amount of effects.
Effects have always had a very important role in graphics, and that will probably remain like that forever. What it conveys is important, but even if you've created something meaningful, and it's not appealing, people won't be able to understand it, therefore, not like it. Here's how I think of
tags, effects are the hook that reel people in, and the emotion is what gets people to recognize the work that was put in. Even if if looks like it's just effects, you have to actually look closely, and not just seeing it, then creating an opinion. When I look at signatures, I look at the amount of work put in. Why? Because if it has a lot of work put in, then it must have the feelings involved of the person who made it.
I don't see half of the signatures I see posted in the GFX thread as real GFX, but flashy rectangles with a ton of effects and random pictures and intricate images.
You may be looking for the wrong things. When you're looking at a tag, don't just look at things like moods, emotions, feelings, stories. Look at the signature, look at how everything is brought together, then think about how much work this person has put into their work. To you, it may just be a bunch of random objects stuck together, but to that person, it's a collage filled with HIS/HER emotions, hard work, feelings. The signature itself can represent how they were feeling. If you add all of this up, you've got a story of how that signature was created. It's not always about how the signature looks to be about it's meaning, but the signature itself. That's why, when I see a signature that just looks like a background an image, I can't connect, and I can't see what kind of work was put into it, it's just too little for me.
If you want this place to be so much like a GFX forum and just love the way they work, why bother ever using the WBO? I rarely see any of 'you' (again, you know who you are) make a legit beyblade-related post, but instead, instead of giving any praise (I understand the criticism you guys give, but ever think about, oh, I don't know, saying what you LIKE about the tag?)
I'm not sure if you know this or not, but the only beyblade related posts I have were from last year, and there was only about 2 or 3 of them. If it's a matter of what people like and what people don't like, I would rather hear what they don't like. That way, I know the points I can improve on. Also, I don't go to this site for beyblade anymore. The only reason I'm hear is because I quite enjoy this little section and community. If all people ever heard was what people liked about them, they would just fill up with only that. It would be like only working out my right arm because it's my more dominant arm. I think it's important that everybody know this, if you only work on what you're good at, then your faults become stronger and more obvious.
**The reason I'm posting this is because I feel somewhat responsible for the change that happened here because I've seen how signatures looked before and after my arrival, with all the sudden sprouts of photoshopping and use of other programs.
**I also want to make a thread explaining these signatures, or their actual name, tags.