World Beyblade Organization Off-Topic Forums Your Creations

Round 4 GFX Battle: Xlr8 Vs NoodooSoup

Jul. 29, 2011  11:23 PM
 
[Image: xlr8vsnoodoosoup.jpg]


Theme: Captain America

ENTRY 1
[Image: wccpsh.png]


ENTRY 2
[Image: imageroun4entry.png]


Tally of Votes:

Entry 1: 13 Votes
Entry 2: 8 Votes

*Voting Closes on the 5th of August*
Jul. 29, 2011  11:26 PM
 
Entry 2! I think the backgrounds much better.
Jul. 29, 2011  11:27 PM
 
1 is way too dark. 2, it has good balance, TERRIBLE text placement though. Eye catching, but!

Overall, I pick 2.
Jul. 29, 2011  11:53 PM
 
there both okay but I vote for 1
Jul. 30, 2011  12:44 AM
 
Score check!

Entry 1: 1
Entry 2: 2
Jul. 30, 2011  1:14 AM
 
I vote for entry 1. It looks better, more professional and it appeals to me more.
Jul. 30, 2011  1:15 AM
 
Entry 1 it was close both the backgrounds look good but the words in Entry 2 made me choose Entry1
Jul. 30, 2011  1:33 AM
 
Entry One because it focuses on captain america because there is one focal and blends well
Jul. 30, 2011  1:41 AM
 
I will have to go with entry 1
Jul. 30, 2011  2:12 AM
 
Entry 1.
It may be a bit dark but is more visually appealing.
Jul. 30, 2011  2:17 AM
 
(Jul. 30, 2011  2:12 AM)blah Wrote: Entry 1.
It may be a bit dark but is more visually appealing.

I second blah. I vote for Entry 1.
Jul. 30, 2011  2:19 AM
 
Score check!

Entry 1: 7
Entry 2: 2
Jul. 30, 2011  2:45 AM
 
The first entry is definitely better. In the second picture, it looks as if Captain America is ready to strike or do something, but nothing at all happens in the signature image ...

In entry one, there should have been even more light, not necessarily spread around the signature, but the current 'highlighted' parts should have been even brighter.
Jul. 30, 2011  2:50 AM
 
I vote for entry 1 cause entry 2 does not have good word placement while entry 1 appeals to the eyes more
Jul. 30, 2011  6:02 AM
 
No. 1 (though 2 is ok)
criticism:
no. 1: lighting (but is really good already)
no. 2: Words need to look better, more appealing background
Jul. 30, 2011  6:22 AM
 
My vote goes to entry two because entry one is a bit too dull and doesn't stand out to me.
Jul. 30, 2011  8:01 AM
 
Entry one. The squares and placement of the letters makes me think otherwise
Jul. 30, 2011  4:16 PM
 
i'l vote for entry2....its more eye catching
Jul. 30, 2011  4:18 PM
 
I like entry 1 more than entry 2...for some reason I dont quite like Entry2's background
Jul. 30, 2011  4:18 PM
 
(Jul. 29, 2011  11:27 PM)BeyBladestation Wrote: 1 is way too dark. 2, it has good balance, TERRIBLE text placement though. Eye catching, but!

Overall, I pick 2.

Exactly.

I vote for Entry 2.
Jul. 30, 2011  5:05 PM
 
I vote for entry 2.
Aug. 01, 2011  7:43 PM
 
I Vote for entry 2 , the metallic effect is too awesome & the topic character Cap. America looks more visible in the 2nd entry , not to mention entry 2 is looking like a HD Sig
Aug. 01, 2011  7:48 PM
 
i vote #1 the background looks alittle more "heroic?"
its a bit dark but overall cool

the second one has better light but i dont particularly like the background color and the text isnt good imo
Aug. 01, 2011  11:33 PM
 
Entry two. I think its a little empty, but the text, and the scratches are cool to me.
Aug. 02, 2011  12:46 AM
 
Score check!

Entry 1: 13
Entry 2: 8

This is interesting, Entry 2 is beginning to mount a fight back!
Page 1
Next