World Beyblade Organization by Fighting Spirits Inc. Off-Topic Forums Your Creations

Round 2 GFX Battle: Xyo Vs BeyBladestation

Jul. 16, 2011  10:17 PM
 
[Image: xyovsbeybladestation.jpg]


Theme: Final Fantasy


ENTRY 1
[Image: dipodp.png]


ENTRY 2
[Image: sigcontest31.jpg]


Tally of Votes:

Entry 1: 8 Votes
Entry 2: 10 Votes

*Voting Closes on the 23rd of July*
Jul. 16, 2011  10:20 PM
 
Entry 1. Although Cloud is such an overused character, it looks cleaner and has a better focal point. Nice use of C4Ds too.
Jul. 16, 2011  10:22 PM
 
Entry 1 looks much cooler
Jul. 16, 2011  10:27 PM
 
I've gotta go with Entry 1.

There's simply more depth to the sig, along with it being much more sharper.

Though I must say, it was an interesting choice to use Flowers in the background for Entry 1. It may just pay off, lol.
Jul. 16, 2011  11:23 PM
 
Number 1 please.
Jul. 17, 2011  3:14 AM
 
The second entry looks much better. Whatever is in the first entry's background is a mess and definitely does not look good. With a character such as Cloud, those shapes and that colour are elements that do not fit who he is. At least, the colour might have passed if it were associated with other shapes, but ovals and [a mess] simply do not match his personality.

(For fairness, I already posted my comments on that second entry in another topic.)
Jul. 17, 2011  3:16 AM
 
Because I personnally love villans, entry two.
Jul. 17, 2011  3:16 AM
 
Woah... so you're saying that you can pre-release your sig before?

I though you could not do this for it will most probably reveal who made that sig.
Jul. 17, 2011  3:23 AM
 
I have to say entry two, the way the light reflects on the characters is very good, I now that is a hard thing to do imo. And I do not now cloud enough to now what his personality is like, but, I don't think that the background is good. Its ok, but I don't think its descripes him well. Seems my opinions are usually close to Kai-V's, whatever.
Jul. 17, 2011  3:26 AM
 
It wasn't really pre-released, it was more 'misplaced in the wrong battle'.
I vote entry 2, because as TFW stated previously, I personally like villains.
Entry 2
Jul. 17, 2011  3:35 AM
 
Entry 1, catches my attention, cloud is one of my favorite characters, ant the background and renders match. And there pretty good.
Jul. 17, 2011  3:42 AM
 
I have to admit if the background was different I would vote for it I vote 2.
Jul. 17, 2011  3:45 AM
 
I know nothing about final fantasy BUT I have to with Entry 2 mainly because it Looks Beast, and I love Villians.
Jul. 17, 2011  4:04 AM
 
I vote 2 Cause I like the flame Background
Jul. 17, 2011  5:31 AM
 
Not big on ff but I have to say entry number 2 the second guy kinda reminds me of an akatski from baritone
Naruto not baritone ha ha lol
Jul. 17, 2011  7:02 AM
 
Entry one.
Jul. 17, 2011  7:07 AM
 
I'm not able to make out what this is since I dont watch final fantasy but I'd go for entry 1
Jul. 17, 2011  8:22 AM
 
Entry 2.
Background and text look quite nice.
Jul. 17, 2011  8:35 AM
 
Entry 1. There's a nice use of C4D's , good text placement and the lighting seems attractive.
Jul. 17, 2011  9:04 AM
 
Whoa, so hard to choose.......
Hmmm.....I vote for entry One, looks simple and clean.
Jul. 17, 2011  9:27 AM
 
Score check:

Entry 1: 8
Entry 2: 10
Jul. 17, 2011  10:53 AM
 
Entry 1 as it has 1 main focal point, and is a nice design, I also like thenbackground for some reason...

Entry 2 seems to have a slightly odd focal point, and my eyes have to keep switching either side (don't ask...) and maybe slightly over burned (think)....

So again I'm going with entry 1.
Jul. 17, 2011  10:59 AM
 
I vote for entry 1 because it has a main focal point and the background is quite different. (Also that Cloud pic looks badass)
Jul. 17, 2011  12:08 PM
 
I choose entry 2 i love villains and i like the BG
Jul. 17, 2011  2:21 PM
 
I'm going for entry 2
Page 1
Next