Round 1 GFX Battle: BeyBoost vs TanithElite

Round 1
BeyBoost vs TanithElite
Group C
Theme: Movies
Entry 1
[Image: xfxjra.jpg]
Movie: Iron Man

Entry 2
[Image: spidermanoe.png]
Movie: Spiderman

Score:
Entry 1: 2
Entry 2: 4

Voting Closes December 7th
Ohhh wow. These two are extremely good. But I'd have to go with Spiderman since its based on Spiderman 3. The first entry looks like an animated movie. . . . who ever did the spider man one did sooo good on that. Kudos
I wouldn't say either are exceptional..
Entry 1 would be better with an actual movie shot, Entry 2 needs to have better lighting and a more relevant background (what is that?)
I chose entry 1, although I do agree with dan about how it needs to have better lighting and a more relevant background.
(Dec. 01, 2011  2:01 AM)Dan Wrote: I wouldn't say either are exceptional..
Entry 1 would be better with an actual movie shot, Entry 2 needs to have better lighting and a more relevant background (what is that?)

It Is A Effect C4d used to create a 3d effect!

The text in both are bad, yet Entry 2 looks better, 1's background is just plain.
entry 1 is just a render and some brushes and text is just too odd so in comparision of both i vote for entry2
One, more effort in it rather than 2 at least it has a focal and some depth while both are exceptionally beginner i choose 1 also in 2 the render take up too much place the render placement is very bad and the effects are mediocre the background as i can see are c4d's try to do the basics more
Entry 2. Iron Man looked like it was made from the comic, not the movie. And the background is, well, okay. It's kind of plain and describes nothing of the setting, which is important in everything. The second entry has a picture that doesn't look as animated and the background is showing what the main photo is doing at the time.
entry 2, entry 1's background is just too simple
Entry 1.It has more effort made to it.I really don't like how entry 2 overused the effect C4D's and Wireframe.It has Bad render placement,although the text is good.
Spiderman seems to take up most of the place in the second sig bu I really like the text my vote goes to entry 1
Unnecessary score check:
Entry 1: 4
Entry 2: 5
I Vote Entry 2 Because Because It has nice depth and good Text
The render placement in entry 2 is bad so I vote for entry 1
Entry 2 is nice made! awesome!! while entry 1 is done with less efforts so i Vote Entry 2
Score Check:

E1: 5

E2: 7

(Correct me if m wrong)
IMO the better one is Entry 0. they both have great faults.

sorry for the insult
LOL so are you gonna vote for anyone? or not??!! (sorry for spam)
Depends.

want it based on which one is better? Entry 2
Based on my liking? Neither
i vote entry 1 the c4d background messes with the flow of the render and the background makes no sense in 2 but they both have great faults
I won The Battle? cause the Date line is passed and i have more Votes? Cruelty....pls declare
(Dec. 07, 2011  9:18 AM)BeyBoost Wrote: I won The Battle? cause the Date line is passed and i have more Votes? Cruelty....pls declare
I end it when I can... I was asleep when you posted that Tongue_out
So yeah! Final score:
Entry 1: 5
Entry 2: 8
Congratulations, BeyBoost!