(Jun. 19, 2020 7:37 PM)Flame-Byxis Wrote: (Jun. 18, 2020 6:20 AM)CitrusNinja3 Wrote: Defense Beys don't particularly enjoy recoil, and the spiky shape is undoubtedly going to gradually generate a lot of rotational recoil. It'll be relatively easy to wear down a Variant combo's Stamina despite its OWD since the contact points can single-handedly decide whether or not a Bey is viable even if the Weight Distribution is perfect for its shape. If you look at Master, which is currently one of the tankiest Layer components when used in Left Spin, it has 4 main contact points with gaps, but the contact points themselves are pretty smooth and the gaps aren't too big, so it's able to deflect attacks more easily. I'm sorry I had to use the same example as before when replying to kai edits, but I just want to get this point across in a way that makes sense to me. Also, just elaborating on what I said before, Duo αpollos did have several flaws, but the spiky shape definitely was the biggest problem. The fact that the spikes were organized into 6 segments arguably did make it worse, but definitely not by much. It suffered from having too much recoil to be defensive but was also too round overall and with not enough space between contact points to be used aggressively, which is what I think will happen with Variant, except it might have a niche use for taking down Perfect Phoenix and Glide combos due to being in the correct weight range and resembling a circular saw. It's probably not going to be useless, but it's definitely not comparable to D2 in terms of performance because D2 was useful in a ton of matchups and it looks like Variant is only going to be usable to win some specific matchups.
The weight of the layer can make a large difference. I believe in MFB Basalt and Death were top tier for their times and both had rather rough outside albeit with an overall round shape.
(Edit: I don't mean to discredit you, you're absolutely right, but Basalt doesn't have the same kind of protrusions as Varient. Counter Leone may be a better comparison, although I don't own it so I'm not sure.)
I don't know about Death (don't have it) but Basalt had very, VERY small bumps. It did have one slightly larger protrusion, but overall it had very small bumps created by slight indentations in the metal. Think of the weakest teeth in burst. Now round them out, and make them metal. That's what Basalt is like.
All of this is without mentioning the weight, of course. Basalt was part of the "Max" release line. Basalt was Max weight, and things like Screw Capricorn and Flame Byxis were Max upper and Max height, respectively. I don't know a crazy amount about the MFB meta, but I think Basalt was the heaviest metal wheel until Synchromes.
Anyway, to stay on topic: From what I know, barrage defense/spiky defense has never been very good. No idea about how well it worked in plastics, but it certainly doesn't do very well in burst. However, the shape may be good for causing bursts(?). It was probably at its best in MFB, where the weight of the metal wheels were able to handle any recoil produced, as well as having significantly longer spin times overall.