Round Two - Block B - [Swordsman Zoro vs. Near]

Poll: My vote goes to ...

Entry A
48.00%
12
Entry B
52.00%
13
Total: 100% 25 vote(s)
I dont like anyone one of them!

Entry A:
Very Simple! Where are the basics?

Entry B:
Messy!Flow and Blending and Lightning needs work!


I vote for A. B is just a bit too messy.
I think A didn't quite understood what "Army of 2" is...:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Army_of_Two

No worries: I should have explained better, but next time, feel free to ask me about the theme, and no, a deduction or disqualification is not necessarily needed...
Although I am a beginner GFX person and currently working on my first one I feel like I need to CnC
A.So much open space. To tiny of an Ash and Pikachu image.
B.Looks really messy and sloppy.
My vote goes for A
THIS. IS. SPARTA!!!!! ...WINNING!!!!!

B is just much more "in-detail". A has just the pic and the fade. B's actually looks right out of a history movie, and that's what I like...
B all the way.

Detailed, and completely awesome.

A... Eh, simple, and really blurry.
Ugh. Entry A is a total NO. I have to go with B, due to the BG color blending, and that A doesn't even look like it was copied/pasted. It looks like the BG was colored over the image to isolate the Render (which even isn't really a render then) which makes it look terrible. On top of that, the smudge on the outside of the picture is unecessary. It looks terrible. Vote goes to B!
my vote is with A
i dont really like either of them to much but A is better
B is the only thing that actually can be called decent. Both are pathetic though.

Voted for B, JUST BECAUSE IT IS MORE APPEALING. Not that it follows any basics.