Round 3 GFX Battle: Xyo Vs Omega

Entry 1 Nice design cool colors
(Jul. 23, 2011  3:32 PM)Novae Rog Wrote: Another thing, where on earth did you see orange? I can't see any orange in the artwork at all.

The stripes on the right, plus some of the other lines in the background.
I vote for entry 2, the theme is abstract and entry 2 is definitely that. The color work well in entry 2 compared to entry 1 as well. But they are both excellent.
(Jul. 23, 2011  3:32 PM)Novae Rog Wrote: The theme is Abstract isn't it? I think the artist has done an excellent job following the theme while entry 2 isn't really "abstract" at all, it just looks like a blue explosion. Another thing, where on earth did you see orange? I can't see any orange in the artwork at all.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abstract_art
Unless it is a portrait or a photograph, you cannot really say that something is not abstract, hah.

Also, you seriously ask where I see orange lines when I clearly described their location ?
(Jul. 24, 2011  1:47 AM)Kai-V Wrote:
(Jul. 23, 2011  3:32 PM)Novae Rog Wrote: The theme is Abstract isn't it? I think the artist has done an excellent job following the theme while entry 2 isn't really "abstract" at all, it just looks like a blue explosion. Another thing, where on earth did you see orange? I can't see any orange in the artwork at all.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Abstract_art
Unless it is a portrait or a photograph, you cannot really say that something is not abstract, hah.

Also, you seriously ask where I see orange lines when I clearly described their location ?

I can't see any orange whatsoever, they look more like a faded grey if anything. Personally I think the use of colours go well together, much better then entry 2's two tone.
It is also close to grey, but there is also some orange because of the blending option that was chosen.
Both of them are so beautiful but I vote for entry 1 for its simple and deep look. I also like the entry 2 but it has too charming colors.
I don't like the entries.
I don't get why you put them to try to do an abstract piece while you know that they are inexperienced.
Their results are not good.
The first one has a lot of random lines and the colors are bad. The quality is not good. Just a bad execution
The second one is really messy. The focal is all over the place. The blue color scheme is bad, no depth, no lighting, sloppy effects , random effects.

None of them get my vote.
Both of them are equally bad/good.
I vote for entry 2. It catches my attention.
(Jul. 24, 2011  9:58 PM)Bladeworld Wrote: I don't like the entries.
I don't get why you put them to try to do an abstract piece while you know that they are inexperienced.
Their results are not good.
The first one has a lot of random lines and the colors are bad. The quality is not good. Just a bad execution
The second one is really messy. The focal is all over the place. The blue color scheme is bad, no depth, no lighting, sloppy effects , random effects.

None of them get my vote.
Both of them are equally bad/good.

Way to waste our time and seem like an overofficious douche. You obviously have no idea what you're doing, seeing as they are both amazing. Quit trollin'.

I vote 2. It appeals to me in the sense that it seems like a more organized random. (Is that possible?) Gah, I can't explain it.
(Jul. 24, 2011  10:17 PM)Temporal Wrote:
(Jul. 24, 2011  9:58 PM)Bladeworld Wrote: I don't like the entries.
I don't get why you put them to try to do an abstract piece while you know that they are inexperienced.
Their results are not good.
The first one has a lot of random lines and the colors are bad. The quality is not good. Just a bad execution
The second one is really messy. The focal is all over the place. The blue color scheme is bad, no depth, no lighting, sloppy effects , random effects.

None of them get my vote.
Both of them are equally bad/good.

Way to waste our time and seem like an overofficious douche. You obviously have no idea what you're doing, seeing as they are both amazing. Quit trollin'.

I vote 2. It appeals to me in the sense that it seems like a more organized random. (Is that possible?) Gah, I can't explain it.

LoL. Admit it or not the entries are bad. I have way more experience than you guys and i suggest you take in and digest every word i say if you want to become better or just live in your fantasy in which you prefer to think that everyone is a great gfxer.

Those entries are far away from amazing and no i am not trolling. i am pretty serious.

Abstract is a way of showing a theme, an idea, an environment without the reality. It is said that: art is not the true. It's a lie that makes us realize the truth and tbh none of this is seen in any of those pieces.

Both lacks composition, both lacks good quality, both lack good effects.

See these pieces:
Compare the ideas, the composition, the quality of those pieces with the quality of the entires and you will realize where they got the wrong path.

(implying: i am not expecting any of you to create those pieces but i am showing you how gfxing is and how it's working. )
"You Trollin', You hatin'." Dude, if you's got nothin' nice to say, you can leave, and don't let the door git you on your way out. (Oh, and those are nowhere near anything seen here. They don't really match the theme, and overall, aren't good.) How do you like your own medicine, huh? Please, GET OFF YOUR HIGH HORSE!

Actually, "Abstract" literally means: " Without reference to a specific object or instance; in theory" IN THEORY. WITHOUT REFERENCE. Nyerp, there went YOUR ideas.
(Jul. 24, 2011  11:13 PM)Temporal Wrote: "You Trollin', You hatin'." Dude, if you's got nothin' nice to say, you can leave, and don't let the door git you on your way out. (Oh, and those are nowhere near anything seen here. They don't really match the theme, and overall, aren't good.) How do you like your own medicine, huh? Please, GET OFF YOUR HIGH HORSE!

Actually, "Abstract" literally means: " Without reference to a specific object or instance; in theory" IN THEORY. WITHOUT REFERENCE. Nyerp, there went YOUR ideas.

I am pretty sure you don't even know what abstract is and you have like no idea what's happening in gfx world right now and you are just so close minded in this community (which lacks good gfxing. no offence. it's just a fact) and you are just getting a bad taste in designs.

Go see what is happening in tagging right now. Go see lekill's work, Amanda's work, Stronger's work, Fraqs' work, bxd's work, what Demented ninjas and team moonlight do. (btw those are the masters of gfxing right now. i am pretty sure noone knows them. ). Compare their tagging with this tagging.

Your eyes have no adjusted to know what to consider to be good art and what is random. This is what's holding you back and believing that i am just here for hating and trolling you need to just wake up. I am trying to help you because i don't see anyone else giving good cnc.

If you think i am here for trolling you need to wake up. I am trying to help you. Some real constructive cnc never hurt anyone.
(Jul. 24, 2011  11:10 PM)Bladeworld Wrote:
(Jul. 24, 2011  10:17 PM)Temporal Wrote:
(Jul. 24, 2011  9:58 PM)Bladeworld Wrote: I don't like the entries.
I don't get why you put them to try to do an abstract piece while you know that they are inexperienced.
Their results are not good.
The first one has a lot of random lines and the colors are bad. The quality is not good. Just a bad execution
The second one is really messy. The focal is all over the place. The blue color scheme is bad, no depth, no lighting, sloppy effects , random effects.

None of them get my vote.
Both of them are equally bad/good.

Way to waste our time and seem like an overofficious douche. You obviously have no idea what you're doing, seeing as they are both amazing. Quit trollin'.

I vote 2. It appeals to me in the sense that it seems like a more organized random. (Is that possible?) Gah, I can't explain it.

LoL. Admit it or not the entries are bad. I have way more experience than you guys and i suggest you take in and digest every word i say if you want to become better or just live in your fantasy in which you prefer to think that everyone is a great gfxer.

Those entries are far away from amazing and no i am not trolling. i am pretty serious.

Abstract is a way of showing a theme, an idea, an environment without the reality. It is said that: art is not the true. It's a lie that makes us realize the truth and tbh none of this is seen in any of those pieces.

Both lacks composition, both lacks good quality, both lack good effects.

See these pieces:
Compare the ideas, the composition, the quality of those pieces with the quality of the entires and you will realize where they got the wrong path.

(implying: i am not expecting any of you to create those pieces but i am showing you how gfxing is and how it's working. )

It's hilarious how you stole those off a website and trying to show off. You fail hardcore.
OT: I vote for entry 2.
Score check!

Entry 1: 10
Entry 2: 16

------------------------------

Bladeworld

Would you happen to be lalws_lo? The way you construct your sentences and deliver criticism while not as harsh as lalws_lo is very similar to that particular member?
Those are not mine lol.I am allowed to quote images.
LOL.

Since when it's illegal to quote images and if you want to live in your fantasy that those pieces are great then i guess i have nothing else to do here.

THere are a lot of cocky and stubborn people who are just not willing to learn.
(Jul. 24, 2011  11:33 PM)Fyuuor Wrote: Score check!

Entry 1: 10
Entry 2: 16

------------------------------

Bladeworld

Would you happen to be lalws_lo? The way you construct your sentences and deliver criticism while not as harsh as lalws_lo is very similar to that particular member?

I am Lawls_lo. i am trying to give some good points and help some guys to learn gfx basics and evolve because most of the cnc here is just bad and not accurate(eventhough most of the members here are too cocky and stubborn to listen). If that's a crime then ban me. I rejoined just to help the society. If you feel like it's a waste of time then ban me.
(Jul. 24, 2011  11:33 PM)Bladeworld Wrote: Those are not mine lol.I am allowed to quote images.
LOL.

Since when it's illegal to quote images and if you want to live in your fantasy that those pieces are great then i guess i have nothing else to do here.

THere are a lot of cocky and stubborn people who are just not willing to learn.

I'm saying your a backstreet driver. You're telling them how great you are, yet you don't use your own examples. Before you can harshly criticize people, you should give proof to how amazing you are, then give it constructively. Do you feel so professional being on a Beyblade website bragging about your skills, which you might not even have?
(Jul. 24, 2011  11:42 PM)Vintage Wrote: I'm saying your a backstreet driver. You're telling them how great you are, yet you don't use your own examples. Before you can harshly criticize people, you should give proof to how amazing you are, then give it constructively. Do you feel so professional being on a Beyblade website bragging about your skills, which you might not even have?


Ok. Since you want to spam here are some of my pieces.
http://fc02.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2011/1...40el9p.png (photo manipulation., I put everything in this piece by pictures)
http://fc06.deviantart.net/fs71/f/2011/1...3ktfl6.png
http://fc02.deviantart.net/fs71/f/2011/1...3ivi55.png (this is abstract)
http://i.imgur.com/ocnhR.png
http://i1091.photobucket.com/albums/i399...ou/abs.png (pen tooled and for the record this is abstract)
http://gfxf.net/di-SN5Y.png
Original : http://i1091.photobucket.com/albums/i399..._stock.jpg
Edited: http://i1091.photobucket.com/albums/i399...e66d-2.png

Convinced or do you want a battle??
If you feel like i am here to waste my time with you then you must be mistaken.
(Jul. 24, 2011  11:50 PM)Bladeworld Wrote:
(Jul. 24, 2011  11:42 PM)Vintage Wrote: I'm saying your a backstreet driver. You're telling them how great you are, yet you don't use your own examples. Before you can harshly criticize people, you should give proof to how amazing you are, then give it constructively. Do you feel so professional being on a Beyblade website bragging about your skills, which you might not even have?


Ok. Since you want to spam here are some of my pieces.
http://fc02.deviantart.net/fs70/f/2011/1...40el9p.png (photo manipulation., I put everything in this piece by pictures)
http://fc06.deviantart.net/fs71/f/2011/1...3ktfl6.png
http://fc02.deviantart.net/fs71/f/2011/1...3ivi55.png (this is abstract)
http://i.imgur.com/ocnhR.png
http://i1091.photobucket.com/albums/i399...ou/abs.png (pen tooled and for the record this is abstract)
http://gfxf.net/di-SN5Y.png
Original : http://i1091.photobucket.com/albums/i399..._stock.jpg
Edited: http://i1091.photobucket.com/albums/i399...e66d-2.png

Convinced or do you want a battle??
If you feel like i am here to waste my time with you then you must be mistaken.

Alright, challenge accepted. I'll make the thread now, and won't reply in this one anymore. I also asked you a question on Deviantart, so I was wondering if you could answer it.
(Jul. 24, 2011  11:27 PM)Bladeworld Wrote:
(Jul. 24, 2011  11:13 PM)Temporal Wrote: "You Trollin', You hatin'." Dude, if you's got nothin' nice to say, you can leave, and don't let the door git you on your way out. (Oh, and those are nowhere near anything seen here. They don't really match the theme, and overall, aren't good.) How do you like your own medicine, huh? Please, GET OFF YOUR HIGH HORSE!

Actually, "Abstract" literally means: " Without reference to a specific object or instance; in theory" IN THEORY. WITHOUT REFERENCE. Nyerp, there went YOUR ideas.

I am pretty sure you don't even know what abstract is and you have like no idea what's happening in gfx world right now and you are just so close minded in this community (which lacks good gfxing. no offence. it's just a fact) and you are just getting a bad taste in designs.

Go see what is happening in tagging right now. Go see lekill's work, Amanda's work, Stronger's work, Fraqs' work, bxd's work, what Demented ninjas and team moonlight do. (btw those are the masters of gfxing right now. i am pretty sure noone knows them. ). Compare their tagging with this tagging.

Your eyes have no adjusted to know what to consider to be good art and what is random. This is what's holding you back and believing that i am just here for hating and trolling you need to just wake up. I am trying to help you because i don't see anyone else giving good cnc.

If you think i am here for trolling you need to wake up. I am trying to help you. Some real constructive cnc never hurt anyone.

Ending this little flame war, I don't think you read my post. That is the LITERAL meaning of "abstract". Interpretation always loses out to fact. Get over it.
hmmm, tough one. going with 1 for this simple reason, i feel more comfortable with number 1.
entry two has better colour contrast. ENTRY 2
(Jul. 25, 2011  12:44 AM)Temporal Wrote:
(Jul. 24, 2011  11:27 PM)Bladeworld Wrote:
(Jul. 24, 2011  11:13 PM)Temporal Wrote: "You Trollin', You hatin'." Dude, if you's got nothin' nice to say, you can leave, and don't let the door git you on your way out. (Oh, and those are nowhere near anything seen here. They don't really match the theme, and overall, aren't good.) How do you like your own medicine, huh? Please, GET OFF YOUR HIGH HORSE!

Actually, "Abstract" literally means: " Without reference to a specific object or instance; in theory" IN THEORY. WITHOUT REFERENCE. Nyerp, there went YOUR ideas.

I am pretty sure you don't even know what abstract is and you have like no idea what's happening in gfx world right now and you are just so close minded in this community (which lacks good gfxing. no offence. it's just a fact) and you are just getting a bad taste in designs.

Go see what is happening in tagging right now. Go see lekill's work, Amanda's work, Stronger's work, Fraqs' work, bxd's work, what Demented ninjas and team moonlight do. (btw those are the masters of gfxing right now. i am pretty sure noone knows them. ). Compare their tagging with this tagging.

Your eyes have no adjusted to know what to consider to be good art and what is random. This is what's holding you back and believing that i am just here for hating and trolling you need to just wake up. I am trying to help you because i don't see anyone else giving good cnc.

If you think i am here for trolling you need to wake up. I am trying to help you. Some real constructive cnc never hurt anyone.

Ending this little flame war, I don't think you read my post. That is the LITERAL meaning of "abstract". Interpretation always loses out to fact. Get over it.

lets end this
i have a website with all the answers
http://dictionary.reference.com/
Bladeworld : Wait ? What ! ! Are you seriously Yd.Alekon from GFXF ? !
(Jul. 25, 2011  9:39 AM)Soul_ Wrote: Bladeworld : Wait ? What ! ! Are you seriously Yd.Alekon from GFXF ? !

lol what? how did that guy got in here?

and GFXF?