This is probably a match up that would be seen a lot in tournaments, since attack seems to be better at the moment, so I decided to test it. The results aren't very conclusive, but it's a start. Feel free to post your 20 round test for comparison. I will probably do some more rounds myself. Maybe with different launching techniques or something
Equipment:
*Parts changed every 5 rounds*
*Valkyrie launched 1st on odd rounds, Spriggan launched first on even*
*Rounds were only counted if both beys were launched with a proper sliding shoot, with the same amount of power*
Valkyrie Heavy Accel vs. Spriggan Heavy Accel
Valkyrie Heavy Accel: 9 wins (3 BF, 5 SF, 1 KO)
Spriggan Heavy Accel: 11 wins (2 BF, 7 SF, 2 KO)
5 draws (4 DBF, 1 DSF)
Valkyrie win percentage: 45%
Average clicks lost per round:
Valkyrie: 1.45
Spriggan: 1.55
Round by Round
Seems pretty equal... Spriggan won in matches and Valkyrie won in clicks lost, each being super close. Definitely need a larger sample set
Tests for the other disks 8/8
Valkyrie Wing Accel vs. Spriggan Heavy Accel
Valkyrie Wing Accel: 3 wins (1 BF, 2 SF)
Spriggan Heavy Accel: 17 wins (8 BF, 7 SF, 2 KO)
5 draws (3 DBF, 2 DSF)
Valkyrie win percentage: 15%
Average clicks lost per round:
Valkyrie: 2.7
Spriggan: 1.55
Round by Round
Valkyrie Spread Accel vs. Spriggan Heavy Accel
Valkyrie Spread Accel: 6 wins (2 BF, 1 SF, 3 KO)
Spriggan Heavy Accel: 14 wins (12 BF, 1 SF, 1 KO)
5 draws (3 DBF, 2 DSF)
Valkyrie win percentage: 30%
Average clicks lost per round:
Valkyrie: 3.25
Spriggan: 1.75
Round by Round
Valkyrie Central Accel vs. Spriggan Heavy Accel
Valkyrie Central Accel: 6 wins (3 BF, 3 SF)
Spriggan Heavy Accel: 14 wins (5 BF, 7 SF, 2 KO)
5 draws (All DBF)
Valkyrie win percentage: 30%
Average clicks lost per round:
Valkyrie: 2.5
Spriggan: 1.9
Round by Round
Spriggan Wing Accel vs Valkyrie Heavy Accel
Spriggan Wing Accel: 6 wins (1 BF, 5 SF)
Valkyrie Heavy Accel: 14 wins (6 BF, 3 SF, 5 KO)
2 draws (1 DBF, 1 DSF)
Spriggan win percentage: 30%
Average clicks lost per round:
Spriggan: 2.35
Valkyrie: 2.3
Round by Round
Spriggan Spread Accel vs Valkyrie Heavy Accel
Spriggan Spread Accel: 13 wins (5 BF, 3 SF, 5 KO)
Valkyrie Heavy Accel: 7 wins (5 BF, 1 SF, 1 KO)
3 draws (All DBF)
Spriggan win percentage: 65%
Average clicks lost per round:
Spriggan: 2.4
Valkyrie: 2.2
Round by Round
Spriggan Central Accel vs Valkyrie Heavy Accel
Spriggan Central Accel: 11 wins (6 BF, 2 SF, 3 KO)
Valkyrie Heavy Accel: 9 wins (3 BF, 6 SF)
4 draws (2 DBF, 2 DSF)
Spriggan win percentage: 55%
Average clicks lost per round:
Spriggan: 2.05
Valkyrie: 2.4
Round by Round
OMG!!!!!! Spread is the best!!!!! Nope, not so fast. I tested it out a couple more times and it turns out it was just a fluke. I don't know what happened. Lucky KO's I guess.
Spriggan Spread Accel vs Valkyrie Heavy Accel
Spriggan Spread Accel: 9 wins (2 BF, 6 SF, 1 KO)
Valkyrie Heavy Accel: 11 wins (5 BF, 5 SF, 1 KO)
3 draws (All DBF)
Spriggan win percentage: 45%
Average clicks lost per round:
Spriggan: 2.3
Valkyrie: 1.9
Round by Round
Spriggan Central Accel vs Valkyrie Heavy Accel
Spriggan Central Accel: 9 wins (6 BF, 3 SF)
Valkyrie Heavy Accel: 11 wins (3 BF, 5 SF, 3 KO)
3 draws (2 DBF, 1 DSF)
Spriggan win percentage: 45%
Average clicks lost per round:
Spriggan: 1.95
Valkyrie: 1.95
Round by Round
So it seems like Spread doing that well was just a fluke, but it also seems like Spread and Central do pretty good on Spriggan. I don't really feel like testing these even more, but if anyone else does, feel free to post your tests here for comparison
Equipment:
Spoiler (Click to View)
*Valkyrie launched 1st on odd rounds, Spriggan launched first on even*
*Rounds were only counted if both beys were launched with a proper sliding shoot, with the same amount of power*
Valkyrie Heavy Accel vs. Spriggan Heavy Accel
Valkyrie Heavy Accel: 9 wins (3 BF, 5 SF, 1 KO)
Spriggan Heavy Accel: 11 wins (2 BF, 7 SF, 2 KO)
5 draws (4 DBF, 1 DSF)
Valkyrie win percentage: 45%
Average clicks lost per round:
Valkyrie: 1.45
Spriggan: 1.55
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)
Tests for the other disks 8/8
Valkyrie Wing Accel vs. Spriggan Heavy Accel
Valkyrie Wing Accel: 3 wins (1 BF, 2 SF)
Spriggan Heavy Accel: 17 wins (8 BF, 7 SF, 2 KO)
5 draws (3 DBF, 2 DSF)
Valkyrie win percentage: 15%
Average clicks lost per round:
Valkyrie: 2.7
Spriggan: 1.55
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)
Valkyrie Spread Accel: 6 wins (2 BF, 1 SF, 3 KO)
Spriggan Heavy Accel: 14 wins (12 BF, 1 SF, 1 KO)
5 draws (3 DBF, 2 DSF)
Valkyrie win percentage: 30%
Average clicks lost per round:
Valkyrie: 3.25
Spriggan: 1.75
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)
Valkyrie Central Accel: 6 wins (3 BF, 3 SF)
Spriggan Heavy Accel: 14 wins (5 BF, 7 SF, 2 KO)
5 draws (All DBF)
Valkyrie win percentage: 30%
Average clicks lost per round:
Valkyrie: 2.5
Spriggan: 1.9
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)
Spriggan Wing Accel: 6 wins (1 BF, 5 SF)
Valkyrie Heavy Accel: 14 wins (6 BF, 3 SF, 5 KO)
2 draws (1 DBF, 1 DSF)
Spriggan win percentage: 30%
Average clicks lost per round:
Spriggan: 2.35
Valkyrie: 2.3
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)
Spriggan Spread Accel: 13 wins (5 BF, 3 SF, 5 KO)
Valkyrie Heavy Accel: 7 wins (5 BF, 1 SF, 1 KO)
3 draws (All DBF)
Spriggan win percentage: 65%
Average clicks lost per round:
Spriggan: 2.4
Valkyrie: 2.2
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)
Spriggan Central Accel: 11 wins (6 BF, 2 SF, 3 KO)
Valkyrie Heavy Accel: 9 wins (3 BF, 6 SF)
4 draws (2 DBF, 2 DSF)
Spriggan win percentage: 55%
Average clicks lost per round:
Spriggan: 2.05
Valkyrie: 2.4
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)
Spriggan Spread Accel vs Valkyrie Heavy Accel
Spriggan Spread Accel: 9 wins (2 BF, 6 SF, 1 KO)
Valkyrie Heavy Accel: 11 wins (5 BF, 5 SF, 1 KO)
3 draws (All DBF)
Spriggan win percentage: 45%
Average clicks lost per round:
Spriggan: 2.3
Valkyrie: 1.9
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)
Spriggan Central Accel: 9 wins (6 BF, 3 SF)
Valkyrie Heavy Accel: 11 wins (3 BF, 5 SF, 3 KO)
3 draws (2 DBF, 1 DSF)
Spriggan win percentage: 45%
Average clicks lost per round:
Spriggan: 1.95
Valkyrie: 1.95
Round by Round
Spoiler (Click to View)