Both are pretty bad. Entry A looks like it has been glued onto the background, and it is totally empty, whereas entry B looks like somebody puked a bright white all over it. I'd rather choose white throw-up than messy, undetailed work though. Entry B.
Alright, I'ma being a jerk and CnC now. Both are really bad!
A: Man, the smudging is just, ugh. I see no blending what so ever.
B: My eyes are burning, seriously. The text is too big and it seems like you are focusing on the text. The effects are too bright, and I doubt there is a gradient map that could go that high in brightness. The text blends in, and the background is fairly simple.
KIU!
My vote goes to A
Text? for me there is absolutely no text... :L
Although it could be my computer acting upp...
(Oct. 30, 2012 7:06 PM)Luck Wrote: [ -> ]Text? for me there is absolutely no text... :L
Although it could be my computer acting upp...
On B, in big blue letters, it says BEYBLADE! in a very akward-hard to see font.
I agree with Shirayuki, both are pretty bad, but my vote goes to A.
(Oct. 30, 2012 7:07 PM)Shirayuki Wrote: [ -> ] (Oct. 30, 2012 7:06 PM)Luck Wrote: [ -> ]Text? for me there is absolutely no text... :L
Although it could be my computer acting upp...
On B, in big blue letters, it says BEYBLADE! in a very akward-hard to see font.
Oh... well I still can't see it , even though i know what i'm looking for xD
My vote goes to A.
Although, as previously stated, both are bad.
Bright... Messy... B, just ow. A, just a lot of smudging (correct me if I'm wrong advanced GFXers!). Vote goes to... A.
DEFINITELY entry A. The effect on B looks down right bad. It hurts my eyes. Although there is no blending in Entry A, I like the smudged background. Both aren't very good, TBH.
So yeah, A
In B, the white things in the backround remind me of the pokemon Zekrom's wings, but white, haha. Has anybody noticed that? Haha, if it is, that seems creative, I guess.
It does look a little like Reshiram's too, though.
I'm not voting for both, just mainly because they both disgust the eyes. So much, I want to cry.
Please, use tutorials to make signatures first, then try your own style.
A doesn't blend,B is just yuck!
My vote goes to entry A!
(Oct. 31, 2012 3:19 AM)Shirayuki Wrote: [ -> ]In B, the white things in the backround remind me of the pokemon Zekrom's wings, but white, haha. Has anybody noticed that? Haha, if it is, that seems creative, I guess.
Are you seeing the same B that i'm seeing? I SEE NO WINGS AND NO TEXT!?!?!?!?
People, u have to learn that this is a challenge thread and not a thread to discuss about pokemon and their wings.
And that doesn't apply to me because the only reason I posted was because I frickin' think that i'm seeing the wrong image...
.... *head explosion*
Ow... My eyes.
To be honest, they are both really, really, bad.
I mean like... Worse than my work. And my work is bad.
I guess, if I had to pick one, it'd be A.
I was just messing around wanted to see what Ive been doing while I was bored. That was the worst work Ive ever done. Thanks for the 'Constructive' critisism. The only ones who gave CONSTRUCTIVE critsism were Shirayuki and Kujikato. any ways worst work I've done.
Look, Pokemon Trainer, this is a GFX battle, which means you should do your best. Not your worst. I have to admit, I was harsh.
Your sig is way too bright. The colors blend okay, but the brightness and text (if you can see it) take away from the sig. Try not to use so much effects next time.
KIU.
So I'm not the only one who's guessing which is which?
That's good to know... i'm still currently looking for the text in her sig :L
I was being lazy yes but there are NO tuts on youtube for PSE and I AM NEVER EVER GONNA USE GIMP! I if anybody would kindly like to help then be my geust.
Don't look for tutorials on YouTube for PSE (What does that stand for?). Half the time, the ones on there are no help. I learned on my own. And again, lazyness in a GFX battle isn't very nice. I'm sure Syco tried his hardest on this. Now, back on topic time.
Please work on this kind of stuff. And seriously, Gimp is way better than what you're using now. I'd think about it, rather than shunning it.
The winner is Syco. Can someone close this please?