entry 2 has 1 vote penalty for not observing right size
I vote for entry 2...although it is not right size...it looks better to me than entry 1
E1..
E2 looks too simple too me..
i like E1 more for the "crushing" effect..plus the image which fit in the efffect..
I agree with Benjohadi Entry 2 is too simple well on the other hand entry 1 isnt
Entry one has too much going on inside it for it to look appealing to me, so I vote entry 2.
Unessesary score check:-
E1:-2 votes
E2:-1 vote,due to penalty.
Both entries are a bit too much,haha.E2 is too simple,while E1 has too much of stuffs.
Entry 1 is way too cluttered atm but the blending is nice. You need to work on composition to bring out the elements of the tag do not center focals ! I like the idea of the tag , it's Hulk escaping from uh .. something right ?
Text needs placement , move it towards the focal and use the rules of thirds to reduce the distraction. The tag has no bright area's except that it is entirely shaded with dark colors. It might be my computer though. KIU !
E2 : Work on more effects , it needs more work. A render and some smudge doesn't help. Fill up the canvas more. Where's the light source ? Practice with the basics and you'll improve. Not to mention that the colors are monochromatic and they look pretty boring. KIU , your improving.
My vote goes to #1.
I'm not sure on this, I'm just not going to vote. Entry one went over board and ended up with something messy, and entry two just needs more work...
I really don't like either one tbh.
2 has nothing but 1 has too much.
I guess I'll vote 1 cause they gave the extra effort to make it better.
Ok...here I go!
Entry 1: Too much going on. Are those C4Ds? I can't tell...
When I look at the signature I focus on the background. It does show a little more effort than entry 2.
Entry 2: It look's a little too plain. It looks like all that was done was put a gradient then throw on a render. Then put the text there.Maybe theres more.
Well the only people who know how much effort they put in is the GFXers THEMSELF
My vote goes to Entry 1.
Hope i didn't offend Whatzzer or DeX...
Entry 1 has a good blend of C4D's and the render, but a little bit more lighting would be appreciated. Entry 2 simply looks like a render of Hulk, a plain green background and text, so my vote goes to Entry 1. To be honest, I can perfectly tell who made each entry.
I'm going to vote for entry 2.
Although it is obvious that entry 1 had far more work put into it, it just looks bad. Far to much is happening in the sig and my eyes cannot focus on any single point in the sig. The render doesn't stand out enough either. Entry 2 is simple and basic, but sometimes that is better than over board with effects. They could have blended in the render more and the text is a bit strange (why is HULK separated from the rest?) but it still is better than entry 1 IMO.
Who told you C4D's where used?! Really?
Haha, i kinda gave way, didn't I?
(Oct. 03, 2011 12:03 PM)DeX Wrote: [ -> ]Who told you C4D's where used?! Really?
Haha, i kinda gave way, didn't I?
Of course it was a C4D. Probably distort>wave or distort>ripple
(Oct. 03, 2011 12:23 PM)othellog Wrote: [ -> ] (Oct. 03, 2011 12:03 PM)DeX Wrote: [ -> ]Who told you C4D's where used?! Really?
Haha, i kinda gave way, didn't I?
Of course it was a C4D. Probably distort>wave or distort>ripple
Yep; Just a rippled C4D by the lookies of things. I think that effect also kinda ruins it, it doesn't fit with the render.
Its just the hulks that i randomly place everywhere XD
E1/DeX: 7
E2/Whatzzer: 3 - 1
Grats!