World Beyblade Organization by Fighting Spirits Inc.

Full Version: [Voting has ended]Killzone Graphics Battle- CRUelty vs. Nano
You're currently viewing a stripped down version of our content. View the full version with proper formatting.
Graphics battle sent out by CRUelty to Nano!
Battle Requirements
-Theme: Killzone
-Dimensions: Appropriate size for a signature (maximum 500x200)
-No animations
-Signatures must be sent in by January 11th

Voting Requirements
-Voters will choose one signature, whichever is best, and tell why they chose that signature over the other.
-NO SAYING 'THEY BOTH SUCK' OR ANYTHING ALONG THOSE LINES, STAY ON THE POSITIVE SIDE OF THINGS.
-You can critique, but it would be nice if you voted, as well.
-Voting will last 7 days (1 week) after entries have been posted.
-I will accept entries.

Entry 1
[Image: Pfnz.jpg]

Entry 2
[Image: k5zVL.png]

Vote away!
Make sure you explain why you chose your vote!
Whoops, should of posted sooner...

CHALLENGE ACCEPTED
Entries are in!

Entry 1
[Image: Pfnz.jpg]

Entry 2
[Image: k5zVL.png]
Why write 'GFX Battle', hah?

I like entry 2 more. The nice colors, blending overall, lighting and text really put it a notch above entry 1. Entry 1 is rather dark, with an obscure background and simple effects. Try using some lighting tuts, and make it more HQ! Smile
Entry 2.

It just blends together better overall.
I Vote Entry 2 it Blends well with nice effect while E1's flow disturbs the sig IMO
E2. Loving the blending, great use of the effect.
E1 is Nice in its own way, but is kinda strange as the render feels out of place somehow Uncertain

EDIT: What is the font used in E2?
Score check!

Entry 1: 0 votes
Entry 2: 4 votes

Only 4 more days left of voting!
I vote entry 2, i like how the render suits the background and it blends well

entry 1 is just a render with some smudging IMO
Entry 2. E2 blends more, and I like the background and closeup.
both entries r nooby to me easy to make out who created who but if compared e2 has good compo and blending other on doesn't blends properly and is way too stretched
(Jan. 14, 2012  7:18 AM)Xlr8 Wrote: [ -> ]both entries r nooby to me
Did you read the first part of the OP? CRU said to stay on the positive side of things and not say both are bad.
Anyway, Entry 2 gets my vote. It looks more professional than E1 to me, and the render looks good with that background.
Cru current score is
E1:0
E2:8
(Jan. 14, 2012  7:18 AM)Xlr8 Wrote: [ -> ]both entries r nooby to me easy to make out who created who but if compared e2 has good compo and blending other on doesn't blends properly and is way too stretched
Serious
R-E-S-P-E-C-T Do You Know What it Means?

If you think ours sucks, try making a better one, and see if people vote for yours in the next competition.
OMG, ily. Kthxbi

I think I'm leaning towards entry 2. Not to say entry 1 wasn't good, but #2's colors seemed to work together and blend. The only critique would be to focus the lighting on the eyes.
(Jan. 14, 2012  7:18 AM)Xlr8 Wrote: [ -> ]both entries r nooby to me easy to make out who created who but if compared e2 has good compo and blending other on doesn't blends properly and is way too stretched

Yes, but both of them are literate, relatively humble, friendly, respectful users, unlike some people here who seem to have a completely unwarranted ego, especially when they don't bother reading the first posts of threads properly, or even bother to make vaguely intelligible posts.

And my vote goes to entry two. Entry one is stretched and awkward, sorry. Work on keeping proportions and not overdoing the blurring there. I've seen plenty worse though.

Both could do a little better with the resizing, I do see jagged edges here and there on entry two. Also, don't include "GFX Battle" in your entries, ahah.

No, these aren't both masterful works of signature-making brilliance, they're learning and improving as they go, which is why we give constructive criticism, not "BOTH OF THEM SUCK TO ME" or whatever.



I vote for Entry Two.

Entry one...seems like the image is quite out of place. It seems quite blurry. I'm not sure if that was the intended effect, but even if it was, it kind of takes away from the signature.

But good job on these. I'm going to have to go to the GFX thread so maybe I can join this. I doubt I'll be good though..
Entry 2 it looks really good and it's clear
I honestly say entry 1. Giving a shading, despite making it blurry, adds a certain sway to me. While entry 2 is clear, it's more up in my face, and I don't like that.

I PLACE MY VOTE FOR ENTRY 2.
(Jan. 20, 2012  1:07 PM)DefStamina88 Wrote: [ -> ]I honestly say entry 1. Giving a shading, despite making it blurry, adds a certain sway to me. While entry 2 is clear, it's more up in my face, and I don't like that.

I PLACE MY VOTE FOR ENTRY 2.
Voting was over like three days ago, I just forgot to post about it, haha.
As of January 17th, the votes were:
Entry 1: 0
Entry 2: 9

As of the CURRENT date, the votes are:
Entry 1: 1
Entry 2: 11

And the winner is...
Me.
I had fun, Nano! Hope we can battle again sometime Grin
Hah, I knew you would win. I can't compete with you... xD

And yeah, it was fun. We need to do it again some time.