World Beyblade Organization by Fighting Spirits Inc.

Entry 1:
[Image: 1zezi9c.png]

Entry 2:
[Image: gbattlenaruto.png]

Voting ends on September 15.

I vote Entry 1 Entry 2 is too dark in some areas and it blocks out the pictures

I vote Entry 1, Entry 2 doesn't feature the name and sasuke kinda rules out the naruto theme. Entry 1 is plain and simple and very good. I vote entry 1.

You realize to eliminate any possible biased votes you're not meant to reveal who did what entry?

Also, I vote entry 1. IMO they both need quite a bit of work but entry one is just the better out of the two.
A lot of tips on how to get better are frequently posted in the general gfx thread. You should check it out and post your creations there constantly to get constructive feedback to improve.

Hope I didn't offend anyone here.

entry1

Erm, the voting is supposed to be anonymous, you know. Revealing the names doesn't help. "

Both entries could be way better, but I vote entry 1. The darkening effect in the middle of sig 2 ruins that render, and there is pretty much no effort put into either one. No offense, but it's true. You should try to get some criticism from the GFX thread here or a GFX forum. If you have a Mac, I recommend GIMP or Seashore. If you have Windows, GIMP or Paint.NET is good.

Fine.................

Please don't make excuses.

ENTRY ONE. Both of them dont look as though that they have lots of effort in it, but ENTRY ONE is a bit better.

Score Check!

Entry 1: 6
Entry 2: 0

correct me if I am wrong

Entry 1 does not go with naruto and leads a whole bunch of work and different colors I would have voted for entry 2 if that dark line was gone and sauske was another naruto Entry 1 gets my vote

Is the picture used on the right in the first entry not fanart ? And of course without permission from the artist.

I like the first one better it gets my vote if it's allowed

I suggest we end this. If entry 1's maker did not asked permission to use that render, then whats the point of continuing this, as it is agaisnt the rules?

EDIT: i have recieve word that the member who made entry 1 asked permission for the render. I still want proof

Sure, let me know what the name of the original artist is and give me the link to their gallery page, then I will start believing you.

He Pm'd me and he confirmed that he didn't ask permission. Please close this.