Round 2 GFX Battle: SDamonCronous Vs Soul_

[Image: soulvs.jpg]


Theme: Neon Genesis Evangelion

ENTRY 1
[Image: neongenesisevangelionen.png]


ENTRY 2
[Image: difqrn.png]


Tally of Votes:

Entry 1: 8 Votes
Entry 2: 9 Votes

*Voting Closes on the 29th of July*
Mistake? It says round 2.
i say number one it looks cleaner Grin and better
I will vote for Entry One! I like the background it has while the image quality in Entry Two isn't that good.
I vote entry 1 they both have similar colors but 1 is better
I vote 2 because of the post the thing is in.
Number one for sure its is really good looking and i like the weird outer glow of the pics Grin
entry 2 better background cooler picture
Entry two, nice use of effects. But the quality, is, mmmm. The first diffidently has a better background.
(Jul. 23, 2011  1:01 AM)Resistance Wrote: Mistake? It says round 2.

Nah it's just posted late. SDamon was away.

I'm voting Entry 2. There's more going on in the sig, the other seems a little flat.

Score check:
Entry 1: 4
Entry 2: 4
Why did you two use noise around the character pictures, it is so ugly. Essentially, you never want to use noise like that anywhere.

While the background in the second entry is still as insipid as most of those that use Cinema 4D renders, at least the light and shadow effect of the picture in that entry is quite good.
This is no place to ask that, reported.
Also number one is my vote.
Entry 2 looks better.
Entry 2, it looks more realistic.
I vote for entry 1...it looks better to me
I vote entry 2, the picture goes well with the background
I vote Entry 1. Looks cleaner than Entry 2. Entry 1 also has a better background.

Score check:

Entry 1: 8
Entry 2: 8

Correct me if I am wrong. I also find this GFX battle as one of the most interesting battles.
Oooh, Evangelion. I like. Grin
I vote for Entry two, it's simply more appealing.
i also vote fr entry 2 but both are great but #1 just looks cooler to me
Voting is now closed.

Final Score:

Entry 1/SDamonCronous: 8
Entry 2/Soul_: 10

Congratulations Soul_!